What I can't help wondering, however, is why these children, and why now? For millenia children have been growing up on farms, having far more contact with animals, far less concern for hygiene, and no antibacterial soaps. Have we bred a super strain of bacteria that our human bodies cannot handle? Or have we bred a weakened strain of humans, unable to respond effectively when exposed to normal germs? Are we too clean to be healthy?
When I consider this problem, ever present in my mind is a picture of a farm family I visited recently in Pennsylvania, a handful of boisterous, happy children tumbling in from outside, covered in farm dirt, drinking unpasteurized milk, and incorrigibly healthy.
Cleanliness is important, certainly, and simple hygiene goes further than anything else in the fight against disease. Nonetheless, I wonder if modern, "complex hygiene" is more of a problem than a solution. Could it be that our hospital birthed, antiseptically washed, indoor raised, well protected children are more vulnerable than their country cousins?Easter Sunday is the most wonderful day of the year! Acknowledgement of this in the "everyday world," however, is so rare that it lifts my spirits to see a few comic strips still honoring the day. (As if my spirits should need lifting on such an occasion!). A few of the comics I surveyed, such as The Wizard of Id, were set in a church without making mention of the reason the characters might be there. Some showed egg hunts and chocolate bunnies. Most made no mention of the day at all. A very few hinted at why this day is different from all other days, including B.C., The Family Circus (I'm sorry I couldn't find a link to the actual comic), and my favorite, Fox Trot:

Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Everyday Life Just for Fun
It is having the desired effect. I still can't say I like the genre, but those particular songs have now become enough a part of me that I should be able to worship if we sing them in church, at least if the volumne is kept at a reasonable level.
Here's a lovely piece of serendipity: On Easter we will be singing two of these songs, Lord I lift Your Name on High (Rick Founds) and Holy and Annointed One (John Barnett). I will be able to sing them because I've been hearing them for a month! (I usually have problems with the odd rhythms, but presumably they have been drummed sufficiently into my head by now.) What's more, when the choir asked for time to rehearse (it's hard to lead a song you don't know) I found myself in the unaccustomed position of knowing a praise song that the others didn't. Was that the sound of hell freezing over? (More likely the sound of hell groaning because a stumbling block has been removed, at least partially, from worship.)Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Everyday Life
- Opening prayer.
- Sing music or listen to performed music.
- Listen to a speech.
- Closing prayer.
I find that interesting because I disagree strongly. It is certainly true of some churches, but I wouldn't say majority—at least it would not characterize most of the churches I've been to. And certainly not what I would consider a more ideal "script" if you want one, which would be simply...
- The Word (Scripture and sermon)
- The Eucharist
There is a place for "performed" music, just as there is a place for the "professional" sermon, each bringing to the service knowledge, skill, and experience above the level of most of the congregation. However, neither should be of primary importance. If the music, prayers, and Scripture reading do not actively involve the congregation most of the time, what is to distinguish it from a concert, or a lecture? Maybe we need more of the "Amen! Preach it, brother!" from the black church traditions. :) There's a reason the form of the service in many churches is called "Liturgy"—"the work of the people."
We are too much a nation of watchers, not doers. We have given worship, music, sports, child care, health care, meal preparation, tax preparation, and even thinking itself over to the professionals. It reminds me of something C. S. Lewis said, in The Screwtape Letters:
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Random Musings
If I'd known how wonderful it would be to have our own tree, I'd have planted more than one when we moved here 20 years ago. This is truly one of Florida's great treasures. And yet if you drive around and look at homes with citrus trees on the property it seems that most people don't appreciate the gift, but let the fruit fall and rot.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Everyday Life
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Everyday Life
A friend sent me the following Frazz comic and I was immediately hooked. The setting is an elementary school, and the main characters are Frazz (school janitor and Renaissance Man), Caulfield (a genius who hates school because it bores him; he hangs out with Frazz a lot), Mrs. Olsen (Caulfield's teacher), Mr. Burke (the school's best teacher, and Frazz's best friend), Mr. Spaetzle (the principal), Miss Plainwell (first grade teacher).

I've never been much of a Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. fan, but his short story, Harrison Bergeron, has haunted me since I first read it, long before frustrations with our chidren's schools brought us head to head with its stunning reality. Written in 1961, Vonnegut's warning is yet more accurate and more frightening today.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Random Musings Just for Fun
On Saturday we went to the Central Florida Fair, old-fashioned fun with rides, a midway, cotton candy, and hundreds of exhibits. I particularly enjoy the 4H and Future Farmers of America presentations. What I like best, perhaps, is that it is SO NOT DISNEY.
This year I again visited my favorite fair vendor, Our Vital Earth. I like them because they sell worm condominiums. That's Porter's term for the product, which I like better than the official name, Can-O-Worms. Whatever the appellation, it's a nifty system for dealing with home garbage. The tiered container (shown here expanded) takes up about as much room as a large kitchen garbage can. You put your organic garbage—scraps (except meat and bones), grass clippings, leaves, newspapers, dryer lint, old cotton socks—into one of the three trays (the bottom tier holds liquid) along with the garbage-eating worms. When that tray is full, put another on top; the worms migrate upward as they run out of food. After a while the worms are out of the bottom tray, leaving fine fertilizer behind. Water and worm urine collects in the bottom; the resulting liquid makes a good, natural insecticide as well as fertilizer. (They also say it's good for sunburn, but I don't think I'd try that one.) It's supposed to be a rapid, odorless process, big in Australia, where I'm told the device is often kept in the kitchen. I'd probably opt for the back porch, but the one I saw at the fair would not be out of place in a kitchen. It smelled better than most garbage cans.
We have no affiliation with Our Vital Earth, nor any other Can-O-Worms seller. We don't even own a worm condo; I just think it's a cool idea. And we may get one yet, once I figure out how to keep a straight face when arranging for a worm babysitter when we go on vacation.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Reviews Everyday Life Conservationist Living
That sentence is enough to make half the readers of this blog think I’m insane, and the other half think I’m possessed. Be that as it may, it’s the best way I know to explain the way I think.
Perhaps some folks think in pictures, or in musical phrases, or in conversations; I wouldn’t know. I do know that what’s going on in my mind most of the time is writing. Letters, essays, explanations, debates, short notes, long dissertations…almost continually. If you’re with me, and I seem distracted, or distant, or unusually quiet, it’s because Li’l Writer Guy has taken over more than his share of brain cycles. Sometimes I have to tell him quite firmly that it’s not his turn. When I can, however, I like to let him go on and on, because that’s the way I think best. I do have my share of inexpressible feelings, but generally if I want to understand something, I must put it into words. Sometimes Li’l Writer Guy’s output even makes it into print, a satisfying situation for both of us.
Okay, so it’s an unusual, but perhaps understandable, attempt to explain the way my brain works—but why “Li’l Writer Guy”? Primarily, I suppose, to prevent his thinking too much of himself. He rather likes to imagine he’s seated in some academic cloister, inhaling the intoxicating scents of polished wood, leather, and books old and new. On the table before him are the paraphernalia of his profession: stacks of books, pads of paper, writing implements, bookmarks, his laptop computer. Lost in thought, he stares out the window, but he’s not seeing the cityscape. Now and then he rises, and paces between the table and the stacks. At the end of the day, he reluctantly packs up, puts on his coat, and steps into the outside world, blinking owlishly and realizing dimly that time has not stopped for others as it has for him. (Any resemblance of Li’l Writer Guy’s fantasy land to the New England Historic Genealogical Society Library is not coincidental.) With all this pretentiousness, he needs to be reminded he’s an amateur, a dabbler, and a pretty ordinary human being.
But why “Li’l Writer Guy”? Do I have some unresolved sexual identity issues here? I don’t think so. Maybe it’s because I’ve always been comfortable with the custom in English of using masculine words for both the specific (male) and the general (male or female). Feminist though I was in my early days (and in large measure still am), I never had trouble understanding that “man” doesn’t have to mean a male person any more than “duck” always excludes drakes. Or perhaps it reflects the dismal lack of literature with interesting female characters in my childhood reading: With a few notable exceptions, female characters were weak and silly; it was the boys who were intelligent, active, and adventurous. Since Li’l Writer Guy has an obvious weakness for books, of course he’d rather identify with the strong and lively characters.
Most probably, as Dorothy Sayers says about her Lord Peter Wimsey character, he just introduced himself one day and I accepted him as he was. In any case, Li’l Writer Guy is rarely thinking about sex. Some would say this is sufficient proof he isn’t really male, but I won't stoop to such low stereotyping. Whether male or female is of little consequence: his sole identity is writer.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Random Musings Everyday Life
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Random Musings
American Sign Language to the rescue! In New York, a choking woman dialed 911, but was unable to speak. Her three year old daugher, whom she had taught some basic sign language, conveyed her mother's signed plea for help to the operator. This recent news story illustrates just one of many good reasons for teaching your baby as much ASL as you can manage.
Learning another language and culture is a huge benefit. Not only does it broaden your understanding and appreciation, it also increases your brainpower! It would be best, certainly, to teach your children (and yourself) to the point of fluency in ASL—and in several other languages as well. Even a little is much better than none, however. Children can sign before they can speak, and anyone who has experienced the frustration of not know what a screaming baby wants will appreciate this means of communication. Signing does not slow down speech acquisition, but rather accelerates it.
Related links
An article about the research of Marilyn Daniels
(author of Dancing with Words: Signing for Hearing Children's Literacy)
An online ASL dictionary
A personal story
Lex America/HIPPO Family Club
(not ASL, but a family-cenetered approach to language learning based on natural language acquisition)
Decisions on when to maintain and when to remove artificial life support are difficult at all times. Ideally, the decision to remove artificial life support is made reluctantly but unaimously by all parties involved, including spouse, parents, siblings, and adult children. When there is disagreement, I believe that a hierarchy should prevail: First the patient, of course. If the patient is not able to express his wishes, and has left no written directive, then the decision belongs next to the spouse. That's the nature of marriage, as hard as that can be for parents to bear.
The case of Terri Schiavo is not as clear-cut as that, however. Although Michael Schiavo is legally Terri's husband, he has lived for years with another woman, and indeed has two children by her. It's hard not to sympathize with him, and many will see nothing wrong with his actions. Nevertheless, by so doing he has forfeited all moral and ethical, if not legal, rights as Terri's husband, and should leave all decisions concerning her care to her parents, who have demonstarted that they truly will stick by Terri, "for better, for worse, for richer, for poorer, in sickness, and in health, to love and to cherish, till death do us part."In May of 2001, Martin and Gracia Burnham took a one-day holiday from their busy work in the Philippines for the New Tribes Mission, celebrating their 28th anniversary at the Dos Palmas Resort in Palawan, a Philippine island province in the South China Sea. Their 29th anniversary would mark a year’s captivity among the Abu Sayyaf, a Filipino Muslim terrorist organization with ties to Osama bin Laden. They would not reach their 30th anniversary. Kidnapped from their beds along with several other people at Dos Palmas, the Burnhams were held for ransom under horrific conditions until a less-than-successful rescue attempt by the Filipino army on June 7, 2002. Gracia, wounded, was the only hostage to survive the rescue.
In addition to being a page-turner of an adventure story, In the Presence of My Enemies, along with Christianity Today magazine’s full coverage of the story, brings up several issues:
The problem of unanswered prayer Despite the prayers of thousands—maybe millions—worldwide for their deliverance, the Burnhams were held captive for over a year, and only one of them lived through the rescue. One day, frustrated after many months of seemingly unheard prayers for release, Gracia prayed for something small but apparently equally impossible: a hamburger. A few days later, they were brought hamburgers, French fries, and Cokes.
The question of ransom The purpose of the kidnapping was to gain ransom money, a major source of funding for the Abu Sayyaf. Many of the Filipino hostages were released because their families and/or businesses “knew the drill” and did what was expected. New Tribes, along with other missionary organizations and the American government, were operating under standing policies against paying ransom on the logical grounds that it both funds terrorism and encourages further kidnapping.
International politics There is little question that the U.S. military, with their experience and technology, could have brought about a more speedy, safe, and effective rescue. The constitution of the Philippines, however, forbids foreign troops fighting on Philippine soil, and despite much anguish our government chose to honor the laws and official policies of our ally.
Media accuracy Gracia had been warned, and was careful to read from written, prepared statements when talking to the press. Nonetheless, many inaccuracies crept in. “The one that really upset me originated with the Associated Press and was picked up by Time magazine. They quoted me as saying of Martin’s death: “That is God’s liking. That is probably his destiny.” I would never say such a thing. In fact, this sounds more like an Abu Sayyaf comment than anything else. I wrote Time to protest the blatant misquote and got back a letter passing the buck to AP. The magazine refused to run a correction.”
Grief and recovery One of the burdens of tragedy is that it is impossible to respond in a way that everyone thinks is right. If you grieve too much, you are mentally unbalanced and “need to get over it.” If your grief isn’t visible and you are getting along with your life, then you are also mentally unbalanced, in denial, or perhaps uncaring. If you pray and grieve for those who have hurt you, you are suffering from “Stockholm Syndrome.”
Preparing for the worst Despite having had “kidnapping training” as part of their missionary preparation, the Burnams were not as well prepared as the more worldly-wise Filipino hostages. During captivity, Martin often said, “If I had known this was going to happen, I would have paid attention in that seminar.” One thing they did remember was that obedience to the kidnappers is of prime importance in the first few moments, because that is when they are the most trigger-happy, and that soon after it is important to make eye contact and become a “real person” rather than an item to them. Some of the other captives were aware and prepared enough to grab suitcases and water to take with them. Clearly kidnapping was the last thing on the Americans’ minds, but others were more “street smart.” It reminds me, on a lesser level, of the time I was rousted in the middle of the night by a hotel fire alarm. I wasted what could have been precious moments struggling to find my pants, my shoes, and my key. Now when I stay in a hotel I make sure they are handy before retiring. A basic knowledge of your captors is also useful. The American hostage who was chosen to be beheaded by the Abu Sayyaf had, possibly unwittingly, offended against the values of his Muslim kidnappers. Finally, the time to develop a strong faith is before you find yourself in a difficult situation. Even with all their preparation and strength, the Burnhams found their faith tried and tested at every turn. Others, who had not given spiritual matters much priority in their lives, fared far worse.
The cluelessness of their captors The Abu Sayyaf may have been quick to be offended by those who don’t conform to Muslim values, but only two of the hundred or so the Burnhams knew about had actually read the Qur’an through—and it’s a small book. Even those two had only read it in Arabic, which they didn’t understand, on the grounds that translating it into a language they knew would have corrupted it. They were quick to quote what they had been told, such as “In Islam, if you're a thief, they cut off your hand. That's how things ought to be,” spoken by the man who had stolen Martin’s wedding ring. They were shocked when Martin suggested their actions might be wrong: “I hope my children don't take up the same attitude you have,” he told them. “I hope my kids back home in the States don't ever get a gun and shoot some Muslim because of what you have done to us.” “Done to you?” said one. “What's my sin against you? I've never done anything to you!”Let me state at the outset that I am in favor of vaccinations. I’m very grateful to all those folks whose work has given us some measure of victory over so many horrible diseases. (And to the animals involved, whose sacrifices are usually even greater.) That said, it needs to be more clear that those little jabs to which we subject ourselves, our babies, and our soldiers, are neither miracle nor magic.
There are always risks, and the only reason for a vaccination is if the risks from the disease exceed those from the vaccine itself. I first had my eyes opened to this when I asked my doctor why smallpox wasn’t on the list of recommended vaccines for our children: With smallpox all but wiped out, and biological terrorist attacks not even on the horizon, it would have been foolish to subject children to the dangers of the smallpox vaccine when their chance of being exposed to the disease was infinitesimal.
Worse than the natural, inherent dangers are the human failings: mistakes, hasty or slipshod work, ignorance, pride, political infighting, collusion, and cover-ups. Much of what I said in my comments on The Virus Within applies to this book as well.
When I first heard that the polio vaccine that my generation received as children had been contaminated because it was produced using monkey kidneys, I was incredulous. What did monkey kidneys have to do with producing vaccines? As Edward R. Murrow asked, when he interviewed Jonas Salk, the vaccine’s creator, “The only thing I know about this vaccine is that it starts with a monkey’s kidney and it ends up going into a child’s arm. Could you explain a little to us the process in between?”
Polio was a terrifying disease that reached from the poorest slum dweller to the president of the United States himself, and pressure to develop a vaccine was enormous. (The recent theories that Franklin D. Roosevelt had Guillain-Barré Syndrome rather than polio are immaterial—whatever the actual cause of his problems, it was believed at the time to be polio.) The task was especially daunting because the polio virus could only be grown in living monkeys: Inject monkey with virus, wait for monkey to get sick, kill monkey, extract virus-containing fluid from ground-up spinal cord. Repeat until you have enough virus to work with. Develop a vaccine to test. Inject vaccine into monkeys. If they get sick, start over—the vaccine isn't safe. If they don’t, infect the monkeys with the virus. If they get sick, start over—the vaccine doesn’t work. If they are protected, proceed to human field testing, first on a small scale that would require the use of hundreds of monkeys, then a larger trial with more monkeys, and finally mass testing requiring hundreds of thousands of monkeys. If your vaccine passes all the tests and is approved for production, it will take tens of millions of monkeys to produce enough for mass immunization. Even if that were possible, it would take years—and America in the late 1940’s did not want to wait years.
Enter the Harvard Medical School laboratory of John Enders, which demonstrated that it was possible to grow the polio virus in certain tissue cultures. (Enders and two of his coworkers eventually received the Nobel Prize in medicine for this work.) Their report was largely ignored by polio researchers, but Dr. Jonas Salk, then at the University of Pittsburgh, grabbed the idea and ran. By growing the polio virus in ground-up monkey kidneys suspended in a nutrient broth, Salk was suddenly producing large quantities of virus in little time. At last, a vaccine seemed possible.
And so it was. Those of us who were born post-vaccine cannot fully appreciate what a miracle the polio vaccine seemed to parents who lived in terror of this disease, which killed and paralyzed and particularly targeted children. But it wasn’t quite a miracle, because there was a time-bomb hidden in the vaccine: SV-40, a monkey virus that survived inadequate purification procedures to contaminate nearly every dose of polio vaccine between 1954 and 1963, affecting about a hundred million people in the United States alone. Even after the contamination was discovered, the dangers were downplayed—contaminated batches were not recalled, but continued to be used—because it was widely accepted that the monkey virus, being from a different species, would do no harm.
Unfortunately, that proved to be a false and costly assumption. SV-40 is now known to be carcinogenic, and since the mid-1990’s has been discovered in many formerly rare brain and bone cancers, as well as lymphomas and leukemias. Is this a cause and effect connection, or a coincidence? The government is still downplaying the issue, as you can see from the CDC’s much less alarmist version of the story. They may be right, and I certainly understand their dilemma, since they must weigh the risks of vaccines against the dangers of disease. Eradication of polio worldwide had nearly been accomplished by 2003. However, some Muslim clerics in Nigeria expressed fears that the vaccine had deliberately been contaminated in order to give Muslims AIDS or to render them infertile, and the vaccination program fell apart in that country. Before long polio had returned to twelve neighboring, polio-free countries, and hundreds of children had been paralyzed. So I understand why the government might be afraid of panicking parents into refusing all vaccinations for their children. Still, I’d be a lot less likely to panic if I were convinced that the government were doing its best to find, publish, and advertise the truth. The Virus and the Vaccine has not increased my confidence that this is the case.

