To all those following and praying for Heather, Jon, and Judy Wilson: Judy's trial resumes this afternoon. I'm no longer there to continue my blow-by-blow commentary, but I'll pass on the news as I am able. Jon is now scheduled to appear as a defense witness, so prayers for him and his testimony would be appreciated. (I find it bizaare that he was ping-ponged that way—he was originally scheduled, like Heather, as a witness for the prosecution—but my prosecuting attorney friends don't. Facts are facts, and you use whomever you need to establish them.)
There may even be a verdict today, so prayers for the judge would also be a very good thing!
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Everyday Life
The American Academy of Pediatrics has recently doubled its recommendation of vitamin D intake for children, from 200 IU to 400 IU per day. Not only is vitamin D important in the prevention of ricketts, but there is increasing evidence that its deficiency can promote type 2 diabetes, cancer, and autoimmune diseases. Some doctors think 400 IU may not be enough.
This recommendation is all well and good, but I draw the line at this: Breastfed and partially breastfed infants should be supplemented with 400 IU a day of vitamin D beginning in the first few days of life. The reason? [B]ecause of vitamin D deficiencies in the maternal diet, which affect the vitamin D in a mother’s milk, it is important that breastfed infants receive supplements of vitamin D.There's a point there. If the nursing mother isn't getting enough vitamin D, one or both of the pair will suffer. And I suppose the widespread recommendation of supplementation is the best a group like the AAP can do to address a general problem. But I would be more inclined to address the real problem by making sure the mother is properly nourished, and in ways as natural as possible rather than through artificial supplements.
How can one acquire 400 IU of vitamin D? A teaspoon of cod liver oil will get you more that, but if you want more palatable sources, 3.5 ounces of cooked salmon have 360 IU, the same amount of cooked mackeral has 345, 1.75 ounces of sardines in oil have 350, and 6 ounces of tuna canned in oil have 200.
Then there's my favorite source: playing outside in the sun. It doesn't take much, although the amount is variable, depending on latitude, time of year, and cloud cover. The factors that affect UV radiation exposure and research to date on the amount of sun exposure needed to maintain adequate vitamin D levels make it difficult to provide general guidelines. It has been suggested, for example, that approximately 5-30 minutes of sun exposure between 10 AM and 3 PM at least twice a week to the face, arms, legs, or back without sunscreen usually lead to sufficient vitamin D synthesis.
There you go: permission granted to play outside a few minutes several times a week. Maybe schools should re-institute a sound recess policy. Northern children would need longer playtimes, however. The UV energy above 42 degrees north latitude (a line approximately between the northern border of California and Boston) is insufficient for cutaneous vitamin D synthesis from November through February; in far northern latitudes, this reduced intensity lasts for up to 6 months. Latitudes below 34 degrees north (a line between Los Angeles and Columbia, South Carolina) allow for cutaneous production of vitamin D throughout the year. [Pardon the source's obvious prejudice against the southern hemisphere.]
Did you note the clever design here? The northern climes, in which sun exposure is insufficient for at least part of the year to produce adequate levels of vitamin D, have the cold-water fish whose oils are high in that vitamin. How efficient is that? It's another indication to me that the system was designed to work, and since babies were designed to subsist solely on mother's milk for at least the first several months of life, it makes much more sense to me for the mother to make sure she gets plenty of vitamin D herself, and to take her baby outside with her now and then, than to give artificial supplements.
Legal disclaimer: I'm a grandmother, not a doctor. This is my opinion, not medical advice. Check with your own doctor, do your own research, and use your own common sense. [No, I'm not paranoid about the recent lawsuits against bloggers...not really....]Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Health Children & Family Issues
The Associated Press hasn't taken up the story yet, though I know from experience that will probably change. I wish private grief could remain private; since it is not, however, I need have no qualms about providing updates for those whose love and prayers support the particpants in this unfortunate drama.
Nearly six years after Isaac's birth, and more than four after she was charged in his death, Judy Wilson's formal trial began. Although they support Judy and never wished her to be charged, Heather and Jon were subpoenaed by the prosecution as witnesses—the only eyewitnesses other than Judy herself. Required to report to the Allegheny County Courthouse by 8:30 a.m. on Monday, we packed ourselves up—three sleepy children, breakfasts for eating in the car on the way, a cooler with lunch and snacks, an overstuffed diaper bag, Jon's laptop bag (Lime Daley service must be available, trial or no), a bag of books, toys and games, plus jackets, blankets, baby slings, and oh yes, legal paperwork—and headed for Pittsburgh, in the middle of rush hour.Eventually we found a parking place and began our assault on the courthouse. If you're going to try to bring half a mountain of belongings through a security scan, make sure at least one of them is an extremely cute two-week old baby. Faith was the hit of the courthouse, winning hearts and smiles all day long, even from people stuffed into the elevator with us—though some folks took one look at our entourage and murmured, "I'll wait for the next one."
After reporting to the witness room, we set up our encampment outside the door, as the room was small and not a good place for two active boys to wait. The courthouse is not exactly laid out to be family-friendly. A door labelled "Children's Playplace" promised to make our stay more enjoyable, but reneged on that promise: children are only allowed in if they leave their parents behind the closed door, and there are strict sign-in and sign-out procedures. Well, the building did originally house the County Jail.... The true function of the Playplace is apparently as a holding area for children whose parents need to be in court and who have no other adult to watch them. Bring your own adults and the cool toys are off limits. The nice lady watching over the often-empty room did thrill the boys by giving them some gummy candies, though.
If the set-up wasn't meant for families, at least the smooth marble floor of the historic courthouse was perfect for racing Matchbox cars. Jonathan was pretty good about keeping the cars away from the other inhabitants of the courthouse, and the people going about their business were pretty good about not screaming when a car whizzed past their feet as they turned the corner.
The people going about their business were an interesting mix. Suit-and-tied attorneys, neatly dressed witnesses, casual reporters, and people so grungy that one hoped they weren't planning on getting anywhere near the inside of some judge's courtroom. People who clearly were comfortable in that imposing and intimidating building, and people who clearly were not. People black and people white, though oddly enough I saw no Asians and heard no Spanish spoken. Male and female there were, but very few on the outer edges of the age spectrum. Jonathan, Noah, and Faith stood out even in this patchwork fabric of humanity.
There was plenty of time to observe the courthouse denizens, because after checking in our chief occupation for seven hours was waiting. There is a definite hierarchy in the witness world, and Heather and Jon were on the bottom of it. Police officers and paramedics have to finish their testimonies early, so they can get back out on the street. Doctors and other bigwigs can't be kept waiting too long, of course, and though the midwives were treated rather shabbily as well, they still came before the self-employed and the parents. I guess they just saved the best for last—from the news reports, it seems the media would agree. But I'm getting ahead of myself.
We spent the morning keeping the boys entertained and somewhat corralled, and feeding, changing, and holding Faith—punctuated by occasional trips to investigate one floor up (where the courtroom was) and one floor down (where the bathrooms were). Memo: if you're two weeks postpartum and supposed to be avoiding stairs, and the ladies room is a very slow elevator ride distant, bathroom breaks require advance planning.
The highlight of the day may have been our lunch break. We enjoyed our tuna sandwiches, kefir, and Hydrox cookies in the courtyard, by the fountain. The boys enjoyed running around (not in) the flower beds, which to our surprise contain lantana—one of my favorite flowers—which I thought would not grow this far north.
If we had been told to come at noon instead of 8:30, we still would have had a three and a half hour wait. The afternoon was much like the morning, only we were all a little more touchy and a lot more tired. Jon created a "nap cave" for Noah out of a table and some chairs; he blissfully slept away a couple of hours of boredom, lying on the floor with some diapers for a pillow.
Jon was to have testified first, but time was getting short, and they (mercifully) decided to call Heather in hopes she would be finished and not have to return for another day. Once again it was a matter of hurry-up-and-wait. She was called up to the hallway outside of the courtroom just as the person before her began to testify. Jon was able to take hungry Faith to her, but the judge was annoyed by the baby noise outside the door. What looked as if it might have been an uncomfortable scene turned 180 degrees when the officials realized the situation, at which point they allowed Heather and Faith to move to a more private (and quiet) spot.
It's a good thing Faith was topped up, because Heather's testimony took up the rest of the afternoon. Apparently she held up well, responding clearly, calmly, and cogently. She masterfully restrained herself from offering explanations and elaborations that she knew were "not her place" and would only rile the judge. I don't think I could have done as well, as frustrated as I am by leading questions and surveys that require yes or no answers to questions that don't have binary answers.
We were all thankful that the cameras were not allowed in or near the courtroom, and that by that point Heather knew the courthouse well enough to return to us via a path that did not take her past where they were set up. Very thankful we were, also, to pack up and be on our way, even though frustrated that Jon would need to return Wednesday.
Since we were now caught in rush hour, we made a side trip back to Carroll Street, where we showed Faith off to some friends and enjoyed a leisurely Thai dinner. It was a great meal, although it was amusing to note that my "6" rated spiciness was hotter than Jon's "8." Jonathan's "2" was fine, however, and he devoured more than half of a full-sized pork, vegetable, and noodle dish.
Rush hour was over by the time we were on the road again, but it was very late before we finally made it home, since we stopped at a friend's house for Jon to help one of their kids with a computer problem. The wait was not bad for the rest of us, however, since it was accompanied by good company, good conversation, and awesome, warm-from-the-oven molasses cookies (yes, the same ones mention in the previous post). But make it home we eventually did, and collapsed into bed. I did take a few minutes to send a "we're okay" e-mail to concerned family members, which turned out to be a good thing, since this blog post has been longer in creation than I had intended.
No matter what those who schedule the order of testimony might have thought, to the media, Heather was the star of the show. The news reports so far, with commentary:
The first one, Monday night, from KDKA. This is the only one with video; click on the left-most thumbnail picture on the right hand side, or click here. Although the report is current, all the pictures are from four years ago. The baby with Heather is Jonathan. It's a good thing court stenographers take more accurate notes than reporters. I can't speak for all of the quotes, but one thing I do know is that Heather did not say that "what happened to their son was not a crime." I suppose that technically that is the same thing as the way it was expressed in a previous report—"They don't feel anyone is criminally liable for this"—but it sure sounds different. Footling breech presentation is what the article means, not footlength.
The best one, Tuesday morning, from the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. Generally accurate, from a reporter who was more observant than most, noticing that Heather smiled at Judy during the proceedings. One misunderstanding that many people would make (as I would have) is that the statement that Isaac "had no pulse" meant his heart wasn't beating, which was not true. Also, although the reports (and, I suppose, the prosecutor) made much of the fact that Heather spent an hour and 40 minutes pushing Isaac out, that's the same amount of time she pushed with Jonathan, whose birth was completely normal. And I spent four hours pushing when Heather was born.
The not-so-good one. Tuesday morning, from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. This seems more of a cut-and-paste effort from previous reports. The statement, "When they learned at about 30 weeks' gestation that the baby was breech and midwives [at the Midwife Center for Birth and Women's Health, where Faith was recently delivered] might recommend an ultrasound or a surgical procedure, the Daleys found Mrs. Wilson," is untrue. Heather and Jon sought out Judy because they wanted a home birth, and the midwives at the Midwife Center do not do home births, no matter what the baby's presentation is. And for a baby to be in the breech position that early in the pregnancy is not unusual, which is why the midwives weren't worried about it. Worse, as an answer to the question of whether or not Heather would have still wanted to continue at home if she'd known there was a risk of Isaac dying, "Yes" is not a fair summary of "There's a possibility a baby could die during any birth. I don't know what I would have done. I can't say I definitely would have transported to the hospital or I definitely would not have."
The local angle. Tuesday morning, from the Butler County Radio Network. Short, but manages to make two new, blatant errors. Heather was 23 years old, not 28, when Isaac was born, and she and Jon did not choose a home birth, nor to be attended by a direct-entry midwife, based on their religious beliefs. Their religious beliefs do, indeed, affect every part of their lives, from birth choices and childrearing to what kind of work they do and how they spend their money. But members of their (very normal) church would sure be surprised to find anything in the Bible forbidding hospital births.
What Heather would like to have been able to clarify in her testimony is the difference between the medical model of care for childbirth, which informs the assumptions of both the prosecution and the doctors who testified, and the Midwives' Model of Care. I trust the defense will do that in due time.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Everyday Life
Three years ago I read and reviewed Lu Hanessian's Let the Baby Drive, and recently my thoughts have been returning to that insightful book. Today's Frazz brought it again to mind.
Hanessian's son began talking when he was 10 months old; combined with her habit of careful observation and her incessant efforts to understand him, this revealed amazingly sophisticated thought processes behind seemingly random or rebellious behavior. Banging a spoon on his high chair tray, as infants do, he proclaimed, "Mah-mee! I'm chopping wood!" When he was three years old he went through a frightening phase of what to all appearances was open rebellion, but which she was able to trace to his terror that he might lose her, as he had "lost" his daddy during a two-week business trip, and as the water goes down the drain and never returns. When she dealt with his fear, the misbehavior took care of itself.
When we began homeschooling, I tried to insist that Janet show her work when doing math problems, as I had done as a math tutor and college math Teaching Assistant. If the teacher can't see how you got the wrong answer, what can he do but mark it wrong? How can he understand where your thinking veered off course and steer you in the right direction? However, my effort to elicit from Janet the thought processes behind her answers merely resulted in extreme frustration for us both. Because I was a homeschooling mother and not a classroom teacher with 30 children to deal with, I was able to discover that, like Caulfield above, she knew all the answers, but could not express how she got them. They were just there. Much later she did develop the ability to follow her own thought processes and explain them in proper mathematical logic; in the meantime, by not being forced to learn by rote the educationally-accepted methods of doing math, she developed her own advanced ways of mathematical thinking, which served her well through her college math degree and beyond.
The connection between this and Hanessian's work is the realization that the actions of children, whether babies or students, have meaning and logic, if we will only take the time and effort to understand. I've been relearning that lesson, particularly as I observe two-year-old Noah.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues
When an article from my "to blog" backlog, a recent post from one of my blogging contacts, and an article from the most recent issue of a magazine I respect all converge, I can take that as a good suggestion for today's post.
Jennifer Fulwiler writes the Conversion Diary blog (formerly "Et Tu?"), which I've featured before (here, among other places). This is her article in America. John C. Wright is a science fiction writer. It was his blog post that alerted me to the First Things article. Read his introduction, but don't settle for his summary of the article. Instead, read Mary Eberstadt's The Vindication of "Humanae Vitae" yourself.This is bound to raise the blood pressure of a number of readers...but very thought-provoking. I can testify from experience to the coercive pressures of the Malthusian movement. It was the Global Warming of its time: part valid concern, part bad science and worse economics, all hype and politics, but a nearly irresistable force.
Perhaps it will turn out to be no more than a post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy to blame so many of the problems that now beset us on the great sea change half a century ago in societal attitudes toward the purpose, meaning, and regulation of sexual activity, fueled by the availability and use of contraceptive technologies. But it certainly bears investigating, for those who can bear the thought.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Politics Children & Family Issues
I hate to give such horrors any more publicity, so if you already view Planned Parenthood as evil incarnate, don't follow any of the links on John C. Wright's post, Footnote to Modern, Ever-Changing, Ever-Evolving Moral Standards. If, on the other hand, you still cling to the hope, as I did for a long time, that the omni-present organization might not be utterly irredeemable, you owe it to your children to take a look (with them out of the room, of course—preferably out of the house). I wish I could cleanse my brain of those cute, Sesame Street-like videos, but sometimes it's useful to know just how bad the situation really is.
I like the idea of socially responsible investing, but this has reminded me that whatever harm might be done by an undesirable gnat stock amongst those in our mutual funds is dwarfed by the camel damage paid for with our tax dollars.
Oh, by the way. In case you miss it (which I recommend), take my word for it that when the folks at Planned Parenthood use the word "abstinence," they mean something entirely and disturbingly different from what you, I, and the dictionary do. So define your terms carefully (and make them define theirs) before conceding agreement on any point.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues
A friend of ours has four children. They're all still less than eight years old, and have yet many years to develop their tastes in music, but where they stand now offers some food for thought.
When the oldest was in utero, his musician mother was teaching at a college, and was totally immersed in classical music, particularly opera. He is now very bright, intense, and serious, with a lovely boy soprano voice and a love of classical singing to go with it.His siblings, all girls, are no doubt equally bright, but their musical tastes are quite different. When she was pregnant with the next two, our friend was the music director of a traditional church; they are now mellow, happy children who love traditional hymns. The youngest spent her formative pre-natal days listening to her mother rehearse with the "praise band" at another church, and she is the rocker of the family—the louder and more intense the guitars and drums, the better she likes it.
"So whence," I asked, "comes the delight all the children have in Broadway music?" "Subliminal," our friend replied. She and her husband sing together every night after the kids are in bed, and Broadway tunes are a favorite. Every night, as their son solemnly informed me, even when they get home really late, they take time to sing together.
No wonder the kids love music, and are singing all the time themselves. And no wonder theirs is such a delightful family.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues
I shouldn't be surprised when what is said in comic strips mirrors opinions expressed by essayists in more serious venues. After all, both get their inspiration from the same human condition, and humor is an efficient and effective way to make a point. Nonetheless, I always take note when I hear the same message from widely divergent sources, as happened when I read in close succession Francis Schaeffer's The God Who Is There and John Taylor Gatto's The Underground History of American Education. When an evangelical Protestant theologian living in Switzerland and a self-described lapsed Catholic schoolteacher from Pittsburgh, writing on issues that apparently differ markedly, make the same historical and philosophical point, perhaps I had better listen.
The conjunction of Mallard Fillmore and Mike Thomas, about which I wrote yesterday, is less portentous, perhaps, but today's has signficant social and philosophical implications.Safe Havens is one of the quirkier comic strips I like to read, but if the following strip is incomprehensible to you, it's not because you don't understand about the mermaid, the grandmother's ghost, the genetically-altered animals now serving as roadies. I follow all that and was still confused.
Yesterday's mail brought a letter from Ken Myers, whose Mars Hill Audio Journal I enjoy greatly. The purpose of the letter was an appeal for support, but the content shed light on the Safe Havens strip.
With my children grown, I have been blessedly even more clueless of pop kid culture than I was when they were young, but I did hear the name Hannah Montana thanks to a friend of Heather's who blogged about the effort she went through to secure concert tickets for her Hannah Montana-crazy daughter. That's all I knew though—she sings, and she's enormously popular with the younger set. Thanks to Myers' letter, however, I know—and worry—more.
So that's the Safe Havens strip, complete with "ironizing quotation marks."
- Miley Cyrus (now 15) plays the lead character on Hannah Montana, a character named Miley Stewart. Stewart has migrated west from her humble Tennessee origins to live in Malibu, to pursue her dreams as a superstar singer known to the public as Hannah Montana. Hannah Montana is thus a persona, an alternate identity assumed by Miley Stewart. Miley Stewart is also a character, performed by Miley Cyrus. What makes it even more reflexive is that Miley Cyrus performs in concert as Hannah Montana, bypassing Ms. Stewart entirely. One might ask if Miley Cyrus is really a celebrity pop sensation, or whether she just pretends to be a pop sensation when she’s in character.
- The image in Vanity Fair of Miley Cyrus [apparently nude, though provocatively draped in a sheet]…has evoked intense media scrutiny and widespread parental anxiety over the apparently important question: Has this wholesome role model been stained by this arguably provocative photo.
- The question moms (and dads) need to be asking is not whether Miley/Miley/Hannah is going to go all Britney on them, but whether their six- and seven-year-old daughters really benefit from having as a guide to growing up a performer playing a performer playing a performer. Just as the most important lesson taught by Sesame Street is that learning must be fun, so the most important lesson taught by Hannah Montana may be that growing up is about learning how to perform one’s life, how to define your identity as a desirable commodity, how to assemble and project the brand called Me.
- The culture of celebrity and personal performance which permeates our society is profoundly destructive. It’s not simply that being well-known for simply being well-known (in Daniel Boorstin’s classic formulation) is a thin and vapid achievement. More fundamentally disordering is the way in which the deeply sensed notion of “identity as performance” promoted in the culture of celebrity undercuts the very idea of reality or real life; more than the work of nihilistic philosophers, the prominence of performers in our society nudges us toward referring to “reality” (with the ironizing quotation marks) rather than to Reality.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Random Musings
I don't recall the era of the 1960s with fondness; it wasn't all bad, but it was a messy, unkind time that accelerated our culture's decline in the areas of civility and decent behavior. However, there must be more of the 60s in my make-up than I thought: I'm finding good reasons to distrust The Man. :)
Just as the National Education Association adamantly opposes home education, the American Medical Association, unnerved, perhaps, by Ricki Lake's popular home birth movie, The Business of Being Born, has taken direct aim at home birth.* Reaction against yet one more threat to personal freedom has come from across the political spectrum, from the far left to the far right. Congratulations to the AMA for provoking agreement between pro-choice and pro-life groups.
Naturally one would expect professional associations for doctors (and teachers, and plumbers for that matter) to fear and oppose anything that threatens to take even a small amount of business away from their members. This conflict of interest, however, does make it difficult to believe that the driving motivation for their actions is altruistic. They would do better, I think, to consider the advice of wise Gamaliel to the Sanhedrin (Acts 5:12-39) when they threatened to kill Peter and the other apostles who were disrupting Jerusalem (and the Sanhedrin's business) with their stories about Jesus:
Leave these men alone! Let them go! For if their purpose or activity is of human origin, it will fail. But if it is from God, you will not be able to stop these men; you will only find yourselves fighting against God.
*If you follow this link to the U.S. News and World Report article, some of you will be particularly interested to note the first comment.
The comic strip Baby Blues, like Dilbert, often frustrates me because of its negative views. Its depiction of family life does not usually reflect my experiences, and the recognition of one's own situation is a key ingredient in good humor. But whenever I begin to decide it's not worth reading, Baby Blues (again like Dilbert) comes up with a priceless strip. Today's says so much on several levels that futher commentary would be foolish.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues
Thanks to John C. Wright for bringing to my attention Story Time by Andrew Klavan, in City Journal.
Read it. It may frustrate you, it may make you despair, it may inspire you; it will certainly break your heart.
Where there is no vision, the people perish. (Proverbs 29:18)
Let me write a nation's songs, and I care not who writes its laws. (various attributions)Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Politics Children & Family Issues
My feminism tends to be of the on-again-off-again sort. As a child—thanks to parents who encouraged me—I never considered any good character trait, activity, or occupation to be off limits because of my sex. I didn't think much about feminism back then; I just acted, becoming the first girl to break the sex barrier in my high school's stage band, and the only or one of just a few girls in some of my science classes. This sounds tame and silly from a 21st century perspective, but it was a big deal back then.
When Feminism became a movement, however, I soon had to distance myself from it, largely because it distanced itself from me. I was (and am) all for equality of opportunity—as much as is physically possible; I don't ever want to see men getting pregnant—but when Feminism veered into being anti-man and pro-abortion, when it denigrated the role of homemaker and made the two-income family first common and then in some cases necessary, and when it invoked "political correctness" over the very words we speak and even started calling God "Our Mother," that's when I turned away. Not from my beliefs, which hadn't changed, but from the movement and the label. Women were now included, and succeeding, in nearly every possible opportunity; it was time, I believed, to give feminism a rest.
Until I found myself for a few years in the company of some people (mostly men) whose view of women was more oppressive than anything I'd known growing up nearly half a century earlier. Then I realized that even a necessary correction to the movement's faults and excesses (great though they were and are) could send us back too far. I actually worry less about those men now than I do about the Princess infatuation that little girls are embracing as they did Barbie dolls. (And still do? I've been out of the scene for a while.) We're still encouraging our boys to be smart and strong and our girls to be...pretty.
How does one raise boys to be men and girls to be women and all to be intelligent, strong, and competent people? The impetus for this post was an article I read yesterday in a church bulletin insert, which included this paragraph.
A godly father has a profoundly positive influence on the life of his son or daughter. He teaches his son the importance of self-control, respect for women, the value of work, and healthy risk taking. He affirms his daughter's femininity by expressing his appreciation for her as a woman. Dads, keep these thoughts in mind as you nurture healthy gender identity in your children.
Excuse me? The best a father can do for his daughter is to appreciate her as a woman? I thank God my father did a lot more for me than that! Self-control, respect, the value of work, and healthy risk taking are things we all need to learn—not just half of us.
I do believe boys need to be taught how to be good men, and girls to be good women, and that these roles are not identical. But could we please find a way to make boys into men without putting down girls? It must be possible to nurture in boys fatherly and protective characteristics without appealing to pride, which generates worse problems.
Any ideas?
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Random Musings
I like academia. I love college campuses, chem labs, and the smell of libraries with old books. Places and institutions dedicated to the advancement of knowledge, to study, investigation, and discussion. In an odd way, I feel more at home on a college campus than in most places. They feel exciting, challenging, and yet as comfortable as a pair of well-worn shoes. That my own college experience differed significantly from my theoretical ideal did not do much to diminish my belief that a college professor had a near-perfect job in a near-perfect setting.
Pausing to let my professor friends recover from their choking fits....Thirty plus years away from the university experience—if you don't count paying tuition bills—along with a fair amount of reading, and discussions with friends who are college professors themselves, have revealed not only that an academic job is not the halcyon experience I had imagined, but that my view of academia as the ideal of intellectual inquiry is also seriously flawed. A recent article at Inside Higher Ed, entitled Does Academe Hinder Parenthood?, confirms both illusion-shattering discoveries. (Thanks to GroshLink for alerting me to this.)
The comments following the article are as revealing as the article itself, which notes that an academic career significantly reduces one's (statistical) chances of having children.
Controlling for such factors as age, weekly hours worked, and race or ethnicity, male faculty members are 21 percent less likely than male physicians to have recently had a birth in their households. Controlling the same factors for women, those who are academics are 41 percent less likely than physicians to have recently had children.
I was pleased to note that the comments were for the most part several steps more civilized than the usual playground taunts I see in comments to online news articles. However, I also noted a disturbing tendency—which may in itself reveal something about academia's view of children. "I was 36 when I felt free to start procreating," "Not once in non-academic circles have I ever heard mothers referred to as 'breeders'—but I hear it from academics all the time," "fulfilling a biological function," "women have family caretaking pressures IN ADDITION TO reproduction," "the male/female binary couple"—perhaps the writers are merely being academic and precise, but terms like "procreating," "breeders," "biological function," "reproduction," and the redundant "binary couple" all sound cold in this context, and distant from the reality of children and families. When doctors talk about an unborn baby at a certain stage of development as a "fetus," they are being technically correct, but an abortion-rights advocate uses the same term to put distance between that being and the idea of a living, human child. I find it quite likely that the very language with which those in academia are speaking about having children would have a negative effect on their own childbearing decisions.
So too, would the attitude of the commenter who calls himself "ScienceProf."
Of course academia hinders parenthood — it’s hard to be a parent when you work 80-100 hours a week. The question, however, is not whether it hinders parenthood, but whether anything should be done about it.
My answer is a flat out No! We cannot and should not coddle to those who make the decision to have children. When a woman has a child it is her problem, and no one else’s. Why should her colleagues pay the cost of her decision with their time? Why should the department be dragged down by having a member is not producing research? Why should a university be expected lower its standards of excellence?
When I serve on a hiring committee or select graduate students to work in my lab, I don’t want any with children. I know that they will be unable to commit the 80-100 hour weeks that is the standard workload of my department. As a supervisor for tenure-track faculty and graduate students, I refuse to accept lesser productivity due to someone’s choice to have a child. Anyone who has a child must accept the responsibility for their actions.
For those who do choose to have children, it is wholly unfair to expect your colleagues and department to share the burden of your personal decision. Their child is their problem, not mine, nor the department’s.
Even with my less-idealized view of the academy, I trust that attitude is not widespread—though I fear it might be. If it is, the problem goes far beyond whether or not college professors must jeopardize their careers to have families. Such a system would require them to jeopardize their careers to have a life. Even the medical establishment is beginning to learn that one cannot require that kind of work load for any more than a short time period and expect decent, let alone creative, work.
I still love libraries, old books, research, and college campuses, and know that there are schools that come much closer to my ideal than most. I'd love to hear about them!Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Random Musings
I recently finished reading a book called The Marketing of Evil: How Radicals, Elitists, and Pseudo-Experts Sell Us Corruption Disguised as Freedom. That's not what this post is about, because while the author, David Kupelian, does have some important insights into how our culture got to be the way it is, his tone is too strident to allow me to recommend the book with particular enthusiasm. However, he cites his sources well, and thus I am able to give full credit for what is perhaps my favorite part of the whole book, the following great quote from G. K. Chesterton.
Sex is an instinct that produces an institution; and it is positive and not negative, noble and not base, creative and not destructive, because it produces this institution. That institution is the family; a small state or commonwealth which has hundreds of aspects, when it is once started, that are not sexual at all. It includes worship, justice, festivity, decoration, instruction, comradeship, repose. Sex is the gate of that house; and romantic and imaginative people naturally like looking through a gateway. But the house is very much larger than the gate. There are indeed a certain number of people who like to hang about the gate and never get any further.
— G.K.'s Weekly, January 29, 1928
It is a great tragedy of our day that we have been all but convinced that the gate is all there is, that the house and fields beyond it are, and have always been, no more than a romantic, imaginative dream—at best. Perhaps we need a Puddleglum to stamp on the enchanted fire and clear our heads.
Perhaps the strident tone of Kupelian's book is, after all, just the un-enchanting smell of burnt marsh-wiggle.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Random Musings
I don't enjoy reporting bad news, really. It makes me sound old and curmudgeonly. Okay, so I am old and curmudgeonly, but that's beside the point. So today I feature an exciting story from the Philadelphia Inquirer: Midwife Diane Goslin has emerged victorious from a court case in which the State of Pennsylvania accused her of practicing medicine without a license by assisting at home births. (See my previous post.) The author of the article, Angela Couloumbis, and the headline writer who created the title, Birthing Women Win Legal Decision understand that this victory is not about one person's profession, but about one of our most basic freedoms: choosing where and with whom we will give birth to our children.
I could point out that some of the rejoicing may be premature: the State is considering appealing the decision, and the court only dealt with the charge of practicing medicine, not with the problem that Pennsylvania is not among the 22 states in this country that recognize the Certified Professional Midwife license. There is cause for joy, to be sure, but not for letting down our guard. But we'll take our victories one at a time, and be thankful for daily bread even if we're not certain of next week's provision.
Anything less would be curmudgeonly.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Health Politics Children & Family Issues Random Musings


