A Sane Woman's Guide to Raising a Large Family, by Mary Ostyn (Gibbs Smith, Layton, Utah, 2009)
This book sounded useful to Heather, who wishes both to have a large family and to retain her sanity, so we bought it for her as a Mother's Day gift. Naturally, I read it first. (Book-gift recipients are accustomed to that behavior from me, I'm afraid.)
I recommend A Sane Woman's Guide to all families who aspire to sanity, even if their hopes don't include a large family. Although I don't agree with all of Mary Ostyn's advice, it's a surprisingly useful collection of ideas in a slim 192 pages, amusingly presented. Here's the table of contents for a quick preview, followed by a few, rather random, excerpts.
- Growing a Family: Are We Crazy to Want Another Baby?
- Money: Just How Broke Are We Going to Be?
- Making Space: Will We Need a Shoehorn to Fit Another Bed?
- Kids and Activities: Is It Still "Home Sweet Home" If I'm Never There?
- Affordable Vacations: Is a Disney Vacation a Childhood Essential? [Absolutely not. But a Central Florida vacation is, if your grandparents live in the Orlando area.]
- The Supermom Myth: Where is My Supersuit?
- Parenthood and Stress: Will Bedtime Ever Come?
- Parenting Hacks: Isn't There a Better Way to Do This?
- Likeable Kids: Will Grandma Be Worn Out by Our Brood?
- School Success: What if My Kid Isn't an Honor Student?
- Encouraging Sibling Friendships: Why Can't They Be Friends?
- Celebrating Each Child: Will They Know How Special They Are to Me?
- Conclusion: Never Alone
Making it work on a moderate income comes down to clarity of purpose. What do our children need most from us? They need love. They need food, clothes, and shelter. The need clear expectations and responsibilities. The need time just to be kids....But they do not need huge allowances, rooms of their own, TVs in their rooms, and name-brand clothes.
Though I am a tightwad at heart, years of mothering a large family have made me a reluctant fan of high-quality components in certain places [e.g. faucets, carpets and other flooring, cabinets, and doorknobs].
Every household should have a good collection of books....The library is a wonderful resource as well. But kids should be able to find something to read anytime, not just when you have time to hit the library.
My mom taught me to sort laundry the traditional way: whites, lights, mediums, darks, and towels. As a new wife, I dutifully emulated my mom's approach. A few kids later, I got lax and tried the "grab any heap and chuck it in the washer" approach. To my surprise, the laundry didn't look much different. Sure, there were those few rare occasions when I forgot about that new red shirt and my (very secure) hubby ended up wearing pink underwear to work. But those times were rare. My casual approach saved minutes every day and decreased our quality of life not one bit.
Instead of aiming to get out the door five minutes before I had to get out the door, I started aiming to leave half an hour sooner. Don't get me wrong: I've never managed to actually leave half an hour early. But often I manage to walk out the door five or ten minutes ahead of schedule. After years of unsuccessfully trying to beat the clock, let me tell you, that's a sweet, sweet feeling.
A huge key when dealing with poky homework-doers is to give children ownership of the problem. Make sure they know what they're supposed to do and remind them that nothing else is going to happen till this is done. Then leave them be. Sometimes kids will need a session or two of staring at the problems till bedtime to decide to work. Sprinkle a bit of exercise in there even if the work isn't done. Chasing the dog around the yard for ten minutes is sometimes just the thing to break the logjam in the child's brain and motivate them to finish the work. But stick to your guns and require that the work get done.
My husband and I only had two kids when we realized that the whining had to quit in our house. We made a serious push to stop rewarding that behavior. Though it didn't end entirely—we still fight the battle some days—it did diminish the level dramatically, which made my job as mom much more enjoyable.
Pick a few essential house rules and stick to them. Here are the rules we have at our house:
- Be respectful to your parents.
- Be kind to each other.
- Work hard without complaining.
Once the child knows what behavior you expect, give consequences with every offense. Too often we parents think we are being merciful when we give kids one more chance to obey, but, really, we are training them to disobey....Kids are smart, and they learn quickly when it is in their best interest. And here's the truth: learning to obey the first time you say it is in everyone's best interest. It makes for a happier family.
Over the years, I've learned to vary the consequence [for misbehavior] depending on the occasion. If a child doesn't cooperate during work time, he'll need to work during part of his playtime. If a kid is cranky and argumentative, maybe he'd benefit from an earlier bedtime. If a child destroys his bedroom, he cleans up the mess. Kids who hurt siblings can make up for it by doing a chore for the hurt sibling....Most kids do not like to do extra work. I will often give a disobedient child an extra job to atone for defiance....If kids learn that misbehavior takes away their free time, they'll be less likely to do the same thing again. I also find that getting a bit of assistance helps me feel more positive towards the child.
I've stopped berating children about the state of their rooms right before they fall asleep at night. No kid needs the last words of the day from mom to be a lecture, no matter how well deserved. Better to brush the clutter aside and end the day on a positive note.
When you're feeding half a dozen kids, you'd go nuts trying to be a short order cook for each and every child. So you offer fewer choices, and kids learn to be more flexible. Here's another thing that moms of many know: kids almost never starve themselves, despite their parents' fears. If they're given a reasonable variety of food, they'll eat enough to live on. Really.
Thomas Edison once said, "Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work." By training our kids to work, we are making it more likely they will see those opportunities when they come along in life. Training should start young. Even a twelve-month old can help put blocks into a bucket. Kids need to know that everyone in your family helps out, and they need to learn that complaining will not get them out of work. In fact, at our house, complaining is a great way to earn an extra task. Even an indignant "Uh!" means kids need to practice giving the right answer in the right tone of voice...Don't just give children busywork. Kids are competent....It is better to overestimate your children's ability a bit and then train them to the task. Don't keep kids doing the same overly simplistic jobs for years. Promote them!
One of the best things we can give our kids is the right kind of praise. Words of affirmation come naturally to many parents these days....The problem is that kids get used to being applauded for the simplest things....Rather than giving huge applause for every action, it is better to praise specifics and to match the level of praise to the amount of effort that the child made....The most powerful praise focuses on things that children can control. We should notice effort. We should notice concentration. We should especially notice when kids have worked hard on a project. In the end, hard work will get kids farther than native ability.
Here's something that a lot of people don't realize. All kids come out of school with "gaps," no matter what type of schooling they've had....But if we can instill in our children an ethic of hard work, the ability to read, and a curiosity about the worlds, they will have the tools they need to overcome any gaps they may have.
When I notice my kids picking on other children's weaknesses, I pick a quiet time to speak directly to the person who is being unkind. "Have you noticed how Ben really hates to wear his glasses?" Usually the child will admit that he has. If he pretends ignorance of the issue, I'll explain the other child's feelings in a non-accusatory way and ask the child if he will help me support his brother. "Could you help me make sure nobody teases him about his glasses? Let me know if anyone does, okay?" Enlisting the child's help as his brother's protector will often discourage teasing. You may not even have to mention the child's part in the teasing. Most likely his conscience will do that work. If we can teach our children to make allowance for the weaknesses of others, we will be encouraging a kinder gentler spirit in our home.
A Sane Woman's Guide to Raising a Large Family is a quick first-time read, during which most people will find sound principles worth re-reading a time or two. It's also well-written, and the tone is not condescending.I've come to realize that fighting between children is most intense when they are having a hard time getting their own needs met. If a kid is feeling neglected or out of sorts, he can't have the emotional energy to speak gently to another child, to forgive, to be kind. Often I can trace an increase of fighting in the family directly to a too-busy schedule, especially a too-busy momma, or to a too-great focus on accomplishment at the expense of family fun.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues
I thought I was finished writing about Judy's trial and the circumstances that led to it, but Jon wrote some excellent comments in response to a discussion at allnurses.com, and they're worth repeating here. (Following the link will take you to the page where Jon's comments are; from there you can see the whole thread if you'd like.)
To the EMT who would get children out of the parents' custody because they don't agree with his advice: That is completely horrible, and unacceptable for any case but perhaps some sort of huge abuse problem. Perhaps you haven't seen what sort of issues there are once the state steps in to take care of the children. Way worse than 99% of the parents that are out there.
The EMT's comment is worth quoting here. Let those who take our basic liberties for granted observe both his attitude and the fact that he said it's "very easy" to have a baby declared in need of protective custody, at least for long enough to strong-arm the parents into obedience.
Actually we can force the mother to go to the hospital, it's kind of a trick but unless there is a religious reason for the baby not to go, we say that the parent's action[s] are placing the child at risk of injury and have the police put the baby in protective custody (very easy to do) and transport the baby, but they're attached so mom has to go.
Back to Jon. Some people suggested that 911 should have been called earlier, that having EMTs there sooner would have made a difference in the outcome.
We do have a phone. In my mind, once a baby is partially out of the mother, there isn't much that an EMT is going to be able to do, so not worth calling. (Now that I've seen what experience the EMTs have with babies (out of the 6 EMTs and physician that showed up, one had seen a baby delivered before, the rest testified that they had never seen a baby that small—10 pounds—or young before. They had no experience with umbilical cords, and depended on the midwife to properly handle that. They had no experience with infant CPR, and one testified that our midwife was doing things incorrectly, but upon further research into infant CPR (I never had infant CPR certification myself, just adult and child) [I] saw that Judy was doing exactly the right thing, and the EMT was referring to child CPR, which doesn't apply to a 10 minute old baby.
As for legality of things, I refer you to the Diane Goslin case last year, where it was clearly stated that PA law does not treat midwifery as the practice of medicine. So, the only thing left was to charge our midwife with the practice of midwifery without a certificate, which for some strange reason, PA requires a certificate, but doesn't have any means of getting a certificate. Many midwives practice openly in this state, sign birth certificate, do the blood tests, apply for social security cards, etc. and the state accepts them. As far as I can tell, it is legal in PA to be a non-nurse midwife. Hopefully this case will urge the legislators to fix the law where they have created a law that is not possible to live by, and the hundred or so non-nurse midwives currently in the state should have some way of following that law.
"The Daleys have used both a certified nurse and unlicensed midwives. Mr. Daley said he is more comfortable with the latter because they are less 'medical' and don't overcompensate for risks in fear of legal liability."
Hopefully that statement came out right—it was given over the phone to one of the newspapers—he didn't write everything I said, and you can probably twist those words to mean things that I didn't mean. I think it is crazy that some doctors think that there "aren't any risks in childbirth if you are in a hospital," and I think that is precisely the reason that there are so many lawsuits—they set themselves up to be perfect, and say that every other case was negligent, etc. In our case, 78 other babies died that year in the county, in hospitals, and none of those deaths resulted in the county pressing charges. I don't know whether the parents pressed civil charges in any of those deaths—they didn't make the news if they did.
One point that someone brought up is that even with a judge who (given his closing remarks) was quite against midwifery, and the actions of this particular midwife, but still could not find her guilty of anything [deserving a penalty of] more than $100 (though presumably he tried as hard as he could) shows that there really isn't a problem with midwifery in Pennsylvania.
As for other facts of the case, you might be interested in our version of the story, most of which did not get published elsewhere, even if it did get mentioned in the various hearings. I was fairly unprepared for the prosecution to not be interested in facts and the truth, but rather just winning the case. I expected the county to want to find out what happened, and have that judged, rather than twisting my words, (even trying to get me to not be able to testify), and coming to our house to yell at us unless we agreed to change our story. Very bizarre.
Link to Isaac's story (You can click on the "page" links at the bottom of the page if you want to start at the beginning; otherwise, you'll be reading in reverse chronological order.)
Lastly, [to] those people who said that our midwife should have left a laboring mother, or call 911 "to cover her behind", seems kind of strange to me. I wouldn't expect any health care provider to stop providing care, unless it was a danger to themselves (i.e. fallen power line, avalanche, etc). Judy (presumably) knew that she didn't have to worry about being sued by us, and so was able to make medical decisions and not legal decisions. Too many medical professionals are making legal decisions rather than medical decisions. I don't blame them, since Americans like to sue people, and I don't know what the answer is, other than never using those professionals, and seeking out people (like the doctors and midwives that we do use) who agree, at least partially, with that statement.
It comes down to an issue of responsibility. I think it is crazy that the government thinks that they should prosecute someone who was acting on the wishes of their client. I think it makes far more sense for the government to prosecute us—and if we had older children I would have been concerned for their safety, since the government can easily take away our kids any time they feel like it, and like the EMT commenting above, lots of people seem to think that is a perfectly acceptable way of dealing with issues.
I was told early on that the state would not come after us, because then it would look bad, and they would definitely lose the case. The media coverage was particularly poor early on, and contained numerous factual errors, and so even our neighbors assumed that we were pressing charges. Pretty much everyone I have talked to has been very surprised to hear that our government is pressing charges on our behalf, without our consent. One humorous point in the trial was when the judge corrected the prosecution when she said that Judy wasn't a certified midwife—that one of "her" witnesses had testified that she was. Apparently, the prosecution is allowed to argue against the defense witnesses, but not her own. Thus, she had to reluctantly accept what my wife said, but then changed her mind about calling me, since that would result in me being "her" witness, and she knew that wouldn't work, given that only three people witnesses what happened that day, and all three are against the prosecution.
I think if the medical examiner hadn't hated midwives so much, we would have had a much fairer trial, and this would have been over a long time ago. He believes that all midwives, (CNMs or otherwise) have no place in childbirth, except maybe in a jungle in Brazil, and should be prosecuted on that basis alone (that we were in Pittsburgh).
I found it humorous that one of the prosecution's detectives recommended to the district attorney that the charges be dropped, that they weren't going to be able to win. He had the luxury of coming into the case later on, so wouldn't lose "face" by dropping the charges. The original detective and prosecutioner would have to admit they had wasted tens of thousands of dollars if they dropped the charges so late.
Hopefully, people in Pittsburgh and Allegheny county will realize what a waste this was, and can figure out how to stop the county from pursuing frivolous charges against people who don't want to be "protected" by the state.
From a subsequent post by Jon:
Oh, I forgot to say, (in response to [someone's comment about the Amish) that I don't know if you think we are Amish (we aren't, though I do see some positives in the lifestyle they lead).
And the media often asks us if we made decisions about a midwife based on religious beliefs (I gather that makes for a more sensational story in the media). I sort of find that question odd. We don't go to a church that believes in home births or anti-doctors or something like that—though there are some who see the legal/medical quandary we (the United States) have gotten ourselves into, and so agree on some level.
But, as best as I can tell, all decisions a person makes are based on their religious or philosophical beliefs. A person's world view has to affect how they see the world and what decisions they make. So, every decision I make (where to work, live and even whether to post on this forum) are all "religious" decisions.
[The] reason I am posting here is so that folks get the true story—when I testified in the trial, I affirmed to tell the whole truth, but the prosecution made it impossible for me to do so, and so the judge and the media did not hear what actually happened. And I suspect the defense attorney knew that things were going to be dropped, and so didn't find it worthwhile to correct certain points.
Here Jon provided a link to his comment here, on The Trial, Part II, for examples of how it was impossible to "tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth" at the trial. [Jon has my complete sympathy. I don't know how I would manage in such a situation; I get frustrated merely trying to answer surveys that claim to want my opinion but accept only multiple-choice answers that often don't come close to the truth.] I've excerpted his comment here.
Hence the vital importance of a free press. Kudos to Jon for making the effort to tell the truth on allnurses.com, and to that forum for publishing his remarks.The questioning was pretty rough. The prosecution made up a number of stories, saying, "Isn't it true that you..." or "Do you remember testifying previously..." and the ends of the sentences were really random stuff. In retrospect, I think the prosecution's goal was to try to get us irritated, which she succeeded with me, and didn't with Judi [not Judy, who was on trial, but a different midwife, who testified for the defense]. I don't know if her stories were also intended to try to convince the judge that they actually happened even though I said they didn't.
Maybe prosecutors need to take an oath of telling the whole truth as well as the witnesses.
I can't remember most of what was asked of me now; I do remember one question of Judi: Do you use pitocin? No. What if I told you that I had talked to some people who said that you did use pitocin? Uhh... I've never used it. Okay, my next question is....
I am not sure if that was supposed to try to make Judi nervous that Lisa [the prosecutor] had actually talked to someone. It seems like a silly thing to bluff on.
Lisa said that when I called her after being told I would be arrested if I didn't talk to her that I said Lee [the defense attorney] was my lawyer, and when she said he wasn't, I insisted that he was. I wish I recorded more of my phone conversations, because that is a complete fabrication. I said that I had talked to Lee, and he had said she couldn't serve me a subpoena to show up at her office. She asked if I had legal counsel, and I said that I had the one friend that we talked to sometimes, but no, we didn't have anyone officially representing us.
I am not sure how she could have possibly heard that as "Lee is my lawyer."She also asked whether Judy had told me that Isaac could die during a breech birth, and whether she had told me that my wife could die of hemorrhaging, and if I actually cared about my children or not. I guess in writing you miss out on the facial expressions and tone of voice. It was quite entertaining.
She also accused me of not answering her questions, but then when I tried to answer them, by asking clarifying questions, she would say, "YES or NO, Mr. Daley."
One line of questioning went like this:
Q. Do you remember Judy telling you that everything would be okay?
A. No.
Q. Do you remember testifying at the open inquest?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you remember saying at that point that Judy said everything would be okay?
A. No.Q. Here is your testimony, read from here to here.
Q. Now do you remember testifying that Judy said everything would be okay?
A. No.
Q. WHAT?!?!?! So, you are now testifying today that what you testified previously was incorrect?
A. No.
Q. It says right here: "She said that Lucille said that everything would be okay." Now do you remember?
A. No.
Q. WHATHAHATATA??!?!?!?!
A. I said that Lucille said that, not Judy.
Quite frustrating,Similar line of questioning regarding whether Judy had done any vaginal exams. Again, back and forth, until she accused me of lying, and changing my testimony. (My current testimony is that I don't remember if she did or not.) What Lisa quoted me as saying 5.5 years ago is: "There was a, probably, I think, when she got there, she did a vaginal exam to see in terms of dilation, whatever. I wasn't particularly interested in that part of it, so I wasn't paying attention." And she somehow took that to mean that I was sure then, and had changed my mind now.
While questioning me about whether I thought we should have transported or not, I said that I didn't think it was a good idea to transport a mom with a baby half hanging out of her. (It seems medical folks are split about 50-50 on that decision—some people say you can always transport, other people say you shouldn't.) Lisa's follow-up question was: And what medical institution did you get your medical degree at?
I guess her idea is that you can't have any opinions about your own medical care.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues
I wrote a long comment to Mark Shiffman's Front Porch Republic article, Why we do not own a Television; not being one to waste an item on a single use if it can be recycled, I reproduce it here. You'll have to follow the link to see the context (and other readers' comments), but I think what I wrote is pretty clear on its own.
To my total surprise and (almost) mortification, I write in defense of television. I agree with some of the comments that DVD is the only way to go, but most if not all of the content I find valuable on DVD originated in the TV and movie media, so despising them completely would be a bit hypocritical on my part.It was Marie Winn's The Plug-In Drug that first alerted me to the dangers of the beast, and when our first-born, at age two, asked to watch Sesame Street at a time when the television was off, I said, "That's it. No more." Had the decision been mine alone, I think I would have discarded the television set altogether, and certainly that would have been the easiest course. What we did instead—because my husband was not quite ready to give it up himself—was to make it less convenient. At first we moved the TV to a room away from the main traffic of the household; later we put it on a shelf with doors that remained closed most of the time. Out of sight, out of mind. We also never had cable, and reception was not that great, and the TV screen was small.
Our first concern was for the effect of watching television on our growing children, so we instituted some pretty strict non-watching rules. This was not difficult for the children, since we started when they were young enough not to have developed an addiction. At this stage it's much harder on mom than on the kids, because anesthetizing lively preschoolers with an "educational" television program sounds like a guilt-free way to grab a precious half-hour of peace. I'm standing here today to tell you that removing that option—and thus forcing yourself to help your children develop the ability to entertain themselves—is one of the greatest gifts you can give to your future self.
And your kids? The benefits of growing up free from a television addiction far outweigh any social harm that comes from not having TV as a conversation-starter. (Our children became quite adept at picking up enough information about TV shows from their friends' conversations to be able to hold their own without ever seeing the shows themselves.) Even long ago when our children were young there were one or two high-quality shows available, but we soon discovered that even a half hour a day of Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood was better filled with real-life activities.
It's also important to point out that, when it comes to creating or avoiding a TV addiction in children, it matters little whether the show is broadcast, cable/satellite, VCR/DVD, or online. We do our children no favors by calling them "TV free" yet popping in a movie every afternoon so we can fix dinner without interruption.
And yet...and yet.... If the only way to avoid the ravages of the beast were to destroy it altogether, I would do so. Taming the beast, however, may have greater benefits. Our youngest's lifelong love of opera began when she was 10 years old and we let her stay up—wide-eyed and astonished—to watch the four-day PBS presentation of Wagner's entire Ring Cycle. Performances were meant to be watched, and if they remain true to the original, television and movie productions give us cultural opportunities often out of our reach in real life. (My definition of "true to the original" is admittedly hazy. I'd call Kenneth Branagh's Henry V a great, accessible version for neophytes, even if it omits parts of the play. But the movie adaptation of The Lord of the Rings fails miserably to capture the book, perhaps because the book was not meant to be performed in the first place.)
Television is also great, as was mentioned, at providing an entryway to books and further investigation of a subject. Ken Burns' treatment of the Civil War succeeded where friends, family, and all my history teachers failed, overcoming my lack of the Y chromosome that seems to give interest to studies of war. "Educational TV" may be somewhat of an oxymoron, but a little, at the right time, can be invaluable.
I could go on—discussing the value of armchair travel as preparation for the real thing, for example—but the point is made. Television and its cohorts (movies, DVDs, computers, video games) I dare to say, are the hot peppers of life: In small amounts they enhance the experience; in greater amounts, they wash out all other flavors; overused, they destroy the senses and wreak havoc on the whole system.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues
More random tidbits found while sweeping the corners of the Internet.
Professor John Stackhouse gives a cheer, a half a cheer, and a hiss to Charles Darwin in honor of his birthday:
[W]e can all cheer Darwin's work in bringing microevolution—the phenomenon of small-scale changes happening within species as they adapt to their environment—into focus. Even "creation science" proponents grant the reality of evolution on this scale.
[M]ost of us will cheer Darwin's work in helping us understand macroevolution, a comprehensive theory of how all species have arisen in the complex history of life on Earth....To be sure, Darwin's theory is not complete in its details. Confirmed Darwinists argue over how life emerged from non-life, how single-celled organisms could have evolved into multi-celled organisms, how various complex organs of this or that organism (most notably the eye) originated and so on. Darwinists also dispute whether the man's own allegiance to "gradualism" was misplaced (as his advocate T. H. Huxley warned him it was). Some wonder whether another understanding of evolution's timetable (such as the idea of rapid evolution in outlying populations—Stephen Jay Gould and Niles Eldredge's theory of "punctuated equilibria") would be better.
Where we theists get off, however, is at the third level of Darwinism, the level of "myth." It's one thing to believe in microevolution and macroevolution. Both of those levels, to be clear, are zones of scientific investigation and disputation. But at the third level—where Darwinism becomes "The Theory of Everything"—we leave the realm of science entirely. Darwinism now functions as a religion, as an all-encompassing worldview and as a "myth" in the anthropological sense—the governing story of a people. It is no longer a scientific theory....Darwinism as myth...makes no room for God or the supernatural. The physical cosmos is all there is—everything important can be explained in terms of physical phenomena. And human behaviour, in particular, is simply a result of the evolutionary imperative to reproduce oneself as prolifically as possible....The world is reduced to a grim arena of competitive reproduction. No more science pursued "to think God's thoughts after him," as the great astronomer Johannes Kepler put it. No more "art for art's sake." No more altruism or heroism or honour.
[H]ere's a cheer for Darwin celebrating the glorious adaptability of species. Here's another for the great sketch of the world as an ever-changing kaleidoscope of variation, improvisation and wonder....But only a sad shake of the head instead for Darwin's dark world, shrunken down to mere sex and violence. There's nothing we can celebrate there.
One of my favorite of Stackhouse's articles appeared in the February 2009 issue of Christianity Today: Memo to Worship Bands: Five Sound Reasons to Lower the Volume. I've become inured to, if not happy about, the necessity of carrying earplugs with me at all times. I never know when my hearing will be assaulted, though I can pretty much guarantee it at theme parks, movie theaters, skating rinks, and—sadly—church. I fail to see why volume levels above the threshold of pain are attractive. "Feeling the music" should be an emotional sensation, not a physical one: with the exception of some very low bass tones, if the music registers on any part of my body less delicate than my eardrums, it's too loud.
But I'm just an old curmudgeon, so I'm delighted to have a bone fide, rocking, electric guitar-playing lover of loud music, who has no doubt already damaged his hearing, stand up and shout—not rudely, but in order to be heard—"TURN IT DOWN!"
I am not 110 years old, friends. I grew up in the 1970s with fuzz boxes, stacks of Marshall amplifiers, and heavy metal bands loud enough to take on Boeing 747s and win. I have played in worship bands for more than 30 years, and like lots of juice running through my Roland keyboard or Fender bass or Godin guitar. Furthermore, I'm a middle-aged man and my hearing is supposed to be fading. But even I find almost every worship band in every church I visit to be too loud—not just a little bit loud, but uncomfortably, even painfully, loud. So here are five reasons for everyone to turn it down a notch—or maybe three or four.
- I know it's breaking the performer's code to say so...but cranking up the volume is just a cheap trick to add energy to a room....Do not compensate for mediocrity by amping it up to MEDIOCRITY.
- [W]hen your intonation is not very good—and let's face it, most singers and instrumentalists are not anywhere close to being in perfect tune—turning it up only makes it hurt worse.
- [T]he speakers in most church PA systems cannot take that much energy through their small, old magnets and cones, especially from piano, bass, and kick drum. So we are being pounded with high-powered fluffing and sputtering—which do not induce praise.
- [C]onsider that you might be marginalizing older people, most of whom probably do not like Guns N' Roses volumes at church. And if you suspect older congregants may be secretly delighted behind their tight smiles, ask them. I dare you.
- [L]et me drop some church history and theology on you. By the time church music matured...in the 16th century, it had become too demanding and ornate for ordinary singers. So Christians went to church to listen to a priest and a choir. The Protestant Reformation yanked musical worship away from the professionals and put it back in the pews....The problem today, to be sure, is rarely elaborate music. We could use a little more artistry, in fact, than we usually get with the simplistic and repetitive musical figures of many contemporary worship songs. No, the contrast with the Reformation is the modern-day insistence that a few people at the front be the center of attention. We do it by making six band members louder than a room full of people. But a church service isn't a concert at which an audience sings along with the real performers. Musicians—every one of them, including the singers—are accompanists to the congregation's praise. They should be mixed loudly enough only to do their job of leading and supporting the congregation.
[C]hurch musicians, if you want to perform a fine song that requires advanced musicianship, by all means do it. We will listen and pray and enjoy it to the glory of God. But when you are leading us in singing, then lead us in singing. And turn it down so we are not listening to you—or, even worse, merely enduring you. I know that is not what you want to happen. But I am telling you that's what is happening.
I would expand the message to include all church musicians, not just worship bands. We attend the most "traditional" of our church's four services, which has a choir, not a worship band, and sings primarily hymns. But the "organ" is actually an electronic keyboard, and a recent change is philosophy has jacked the sound up to the point where I must wear my earplugs almost every time we sing. It's not easy to sing with earplugs, and I have some concern about blend and pitch...but console myself with the thought that no one can hear me over the organ anyway. But when the "old, deaf" people in your service complain that the music is too loud, maybe it's time to rethink.
Let me add one more reason to Stackhouse's list:
- The church, of all places, should be "safe," especially for children. In all too many church services, however, babies and children who have no choice nor chance of escape are assailed by sound volumes that threaten to damage their hearing. If we do not fear the wrath of God for injuring his little ones, let's at least fear the potential for crippling lawsuits.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Health Children & Family Issues Random Musings
This Stone Soup cartoon makes me think, not of our children, who have learned from us and built well upon what they've learned, so that we in our turn have learned from them, but about our society in general, as we (re)discover the virtues of thrift and living within one's means; of childbirth as a natural, personal process; of breastfeeding; of small farms and organically-grown food; of respecting, enjoying, and conserving our natural environment. We knew all this 40 years ago; how did we fail to pass it on? Probably in the same way our parents' and grandparents' generations failed to pass their virtues on to us....
Not that progress isn't being made: somehow we've managed to make smoke-free airplanes and restaurants stick, for one thing; and many in the next generation are rediscovering what was lost between our parents' generation and ours: the blessings of having many children. :)Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Just for Fun
I have no more information yet than is in this Post-Gazette article, but it looks as if the seven-year ordeal is finally over. If it's not the vindication and ringing endorsement of birthing rights I was hoping for, it's probably the best we could have hoped for from a judge who is also a doctor. I'm not sure how he managed to convict Judy for not having a license, since Pennsylvania doesn't license Certiied Professional Midwives, but I can't imagine Judy will not pay the $100 fine and move on. Other midwives have pled guitly to worse in order to stop the torture and expense.
Perhaps the Amish, who rely on non-nurse midwives like Judy, will—if reluctantly—push harder for better midwifery laws in Pennsylvania.
Judith A. Wilson, 53, of Portersville, was found not guilty by Common Pleas Judge Donald E. Machen of the most serious charges [involuntary manslaughter and child endangerment], but found guilty of practicing midwifery without a certificate. She was fined $100.
Life has not stopped for us, no more than for Judy, in these seven years, but it is very good not to have this sword dangling over our necks anymore.
I hope to learn more—news reports, especially initial ones, being suspect—and will fill in here when I can. Thanks to so many of you for your earnest prayers for us all. (Earlier posts on this subject are The Trial, Part II; The Trial; and Options In Childbirth: A Personal Odyssey.)Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Everyday Life
Three diverse takes on China:
Although written nearly a year ago (note the line, "Assuming that the global economy does not decline now, it will at some point"), George Friedman's geopolitical analysis of China (via InvestorsInsight) is perhaps frightening, perhaps reassuring, but certainly fascinating. The concluding summary provides an introduction to the ideas, though it by no means does justice to the long article.Geopolitics is based on geography and politics. Politics is built on two foundations: military and economic. The two interact and support each other but are ultimately distinct. For China, securing its buffer regions generally eliminates military problems. What problems are left for China are long-term issues concerning northeastern Manchuria and the balance of power in the Pacific.
China's geopolitical problem is economic. Its first geopolitical imperative, maintain the unity of Han China, and its third, protect the coast, are both more deeply affected by economic considerations than military ones. Its internal and external political problems flow from economics. The dramatic economic development of the last generation has been ruthlessly geographic. This development has benefited the coast and left the interior—the vast majority of Chinese—behind. It has also left China vulnerable to global economic forces that it cannot control and cannot accommodate. This is not new in Chinese history, but its usual resolution is in regionalism and the weakening of the central government. Deng's gamble is being played out by his successors. He dealt the hand. They have to play it.
The question on the table is whether the economic basis of China is a foundation or a balancing act. If the former, it can last a long time. If the latter, everyone falls down eventually. There appears to be little evidence that it is a foundation. It excludes most of the Chinese from the game, people who are making less than $100 a month. That is a balancing act and it threatens the first geopolitical imperative of China: protecting the unity of the Han Chinese.
A recent Slate article by William Saletan highlights another destabilizing factor in China: the bitter consequences of the government's one-child policy. Bizarrely, the author manages to find a postive twist, but he can't change the facts.
Sixteen million girls are missing in China. And now we know what happened to them: They were aborted because they weren't boys.
Worldwide, the number of boys born per 100 girls ranges from 103 to 107. (The numbers later equalize due to higher male mortality.) Among Chinese children born from 1985 to 1989, the number of boys per 100 girls was 108, close to normal. But among those born from 2000 to 2004, the number rose to 124.
[T]he boy-girl ratio escalates radically among children who were born second or third in their respective families.....For third births, the sex ratio rose to over 200 in four provinces.
Two hundred boys for every 100 girls. The number is mind-boggling.
[T]he "one-child" policy [limits] family size but allows exceptions, with variations from province to province, for couples who have only daughters. Essentially, the exceptions give you a second or, in some cases, a third chance to have a son. That's why, as couples approach the family size limit or the exception allotment, the boy-girl ratio goes up. You get the ultrasound, and if the fetus is a girl, you abort it and try again for a son.
The government...has openly expressed concerns about the consequences of large numbers of excess men for societal stability and security....The old problem was too many children. The new problem is too few girls. Without enough girls, the boys become unruly.
Finally, for a less depressing look at China, visit the Virtual Forbidden City. I haven't downloaded it myself yet, but include it here because I hope to get to it, eventually—and because I know there are those of my readers who will immediately pull out their virtual passports.
The Forbidden City: Beyond Space and Time is a partnership between IBM and the Palace Museum in Beijing, China....[It] is the world's first online virtual world dedicated to a country's cultural heritage. This is presented as a three-dimensional replica of the square-kilometer palace grounds called The Virtual Forbidden City. The project partners' goal was to create an experience that is as authentic as possible by being true to important Chinese principles of balance and harmony.
Rather than being an isolating virtual experience, the Virtual Forbidden City allows visitors to see and interact with each other and with a wide range of volunteers, staff, and automated characters. To welcome the broadest range of visitors, a simple, easy to use interface guides interactions with the Virtual Forbidden City. As they explore the Virtual Forbidden City, visitors can choose to simply observe the buzz of activity, participate in activities that provide insights into important aspects of the Qing dynasty, or even take guided tours that uncover new insights into the stories of the Forbidden City.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Politics Children & Family Issues Random Musings Just for Fun
From the frequency of my posting recently, my overwhelmed readers can see I'm hacking away at a hugh backlog. Here's another in the Casting the Net series, which makes the job easier for me, if not for you. The good news is, like the can't-pass-this-up offer at the bottom of my inbox, and that $1 off coupon that's been in my wallet for six months, several of my must-posts are enough out of date I can cheerfully hit the delete key and not trouble you with them.
Free-Range Kids. I've only begun to explore Lenore Skenazy's site, but I like the premise, and it goes well with this cartoon. Skenazy found herself plunged into controversy after whe wrote a column for The New York Sun entitled, Why I Let My 9-Year-Old Ride the Subway Alone.
I started this site for anyone who thinks that kids need a little more freedom and would like to connect to people who feel the same way. We are not daredevils. We believe in life jackets and bike helmets and air bags. But we also believe in independence. Children, like chickens, deserve a life outside the cage. The overprotected life is stunting and stifling, not to mention boring for all concerned. So here’s to Free Range Kids, raised by Free Range Parents willing to take some heat. I hope this web site encourages us all to think outside the house.
George F. Will's What Fear of Liability Has Wrought has unfortunately not gone out of date.
Called to a Florida school that could not cope, police led the disorderly student away in handcuffs, all 40 pounds of her 5-year-old self....No official at the...school would put a restraining arm around the misbehaving child lest he or she be sued, as a young member of Teach for America was...because the teacher put a hand on the back of a turbulent seventh-grader to direct him to leave the classroom.
In Indiana, a boy did what boys [and girls, I might add] do: He went down a slide head first—and broke his femur. The school district was sued for inadequate supervision.
A volunteer for a Catholic charity in Milwaukee ran a red light and seriously injured another person. Because the volunteer did not have deep pockets, the injured person sued the archdiocese—successfully, for $17 million.
The warning label on a five-inch fishing lure with a three-pronged hook says, "Harmful if swallowed"; the label on a letter opener says, "Safety goggles recommended."
The thread connecting such lunacies is a fear permeating American life. It is, alas, a sensible fear arising from America's increasingly perverse legal culture that is the subject of what surely will be 2009's most needed book on public affairs—[attorney Philip] Howard's Life Without Lawyers: Liberating Americans from Too Much Law.
Time was, rights were defensive. They were to prevent government from doing things to you. Today, rights increasingly are offensive weapons wielded to inflict demands on other people, using state power for private aggrandizement. The multiplication of rights, each lacking limiting principles, multiplies nonnegotiable conflicts.
But in such a society, dazed by what Howard calls "rule stupor" and victimized by litigious "victims," the incentives are for intensified complaining. Read Howard's book, and weep for the death of common sense.
Babies Know: A Little Dirt Is Good for You, from Jane E. Brody in The New York Times. Handwashing is a good thing, especially after using the bathroom, before preparing food, and during the time in our church service between the Peace, in which we've shaken hands with anyone and everyone we can reach, and the Eucharist, in which the bread is placed in those same hands and tranferred directly to our mouths. Nonetheless, I agree that the germ-free life, like the risk-free life decried above, is unheathy, especially for our children.
In studies of what is called the hygiene hypothesis, researchers are concluding that organisms like the millions of bacteria, viruses and especially worms that enter the body along with “dirt” spur the development of a healthy immune system. Several continuing studies suggest that worms may help to redirect an immune system that has gone awry and resulted in autoimmune disorders, allergies and asthma.
“What a child is doing when he puts things in his mouth is allowing his immune response to explore his environment,” Mary Ruebush, a microbiology and immunology instructor, wrote in her new book, “Why Dirt Is Good” (Kaplan). “Not only does this allow for ‘practice’ of immune responses, which will be necessary for protection, but it also plays a critical role in teaching the immature immune response what is best ignored.”
“Children raised in an ultraclean environment,” [said Dr. Joel V. Weinstock, the director of gastroenterology and hepatology at Tufts Medical Center in Boston], “are not being exposed to organisms that help them develop appropriate immune regulatory circuits.”
Studies he has conducted with Dr. David Elliott, a gastroenterologist and immunologist at the University of Iowa, indicate that intestinal worms, which have been all but eliminated in developed countries, are “likely to be the biggest player” in regulating the immune system to respond appropriately, Dr. Elliott said in an interview. He added that bacterial and viral infections seem to influence the immune system in the same way, but not as forcefully.
Most worms are harmless, especially in well-nourished people, Dr. Weinstock said.
Amen to all but the last statement, which unfortunately would discourage visits from Grandma: having cats as pets did not teach my own immune system not to overreact to the presence of their dander.Dr. Ruebush deplores the current fetish for the hundreds of antibacterial products that convey a false sense of security and may actually foster the development of antibiotic-resistant, disease-causing bacteria. Plain soap and water are all that are needed to become clean, she noted.
“I certainly recommend washing your hands after using the bathroom, before eating, after changing a diaper, before and after handling food,” and whenever they’re visibly soiled, she wrote. When no running water is available and cleaning hands is essential, she suggests an alcohol-based hand sanitizer.
Dr. Weinstock goes even further. “Children should be allowed to go barefoot in the dirt, play in the dirt, and not have to wash their hands when they come in to eat,” he said. He and Dr. Elliott pointed out that children who grow up on farms and are frequently exposed to worms and other organisms from farm animals are much less likely to develop allergies and autoimmune diseases.
Also helpful, he said, is to “let kids have two dogs and a cat,” which will expose them to intestinal worms that can promote a healthy immune system.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Health Children & Family Issues Random Musings
The story above is from a Scientific American Mind article entitled The Secret to Raising Smart Kids. (I've changed the name because in the original it is "Jonathan." Apologies to any Marcuses who might read this.) I insist that Marcus was probably right: most seventh grade schoolwork is boring and pointless. Be that as it may, the article investigates a question I have wrestled with for decades: Why do so many bright students fail of their promise, surpassed sooner or later by their apparently average, ordinary classmates?A brilliant student, Marcus sailed through grade school. He completed his assignments easily and routinely earned As. Marcus puzzled over why some of his classmates struggled, and his parents told him he had a special gift. In the seventh grade, however, Marcus suddenly lost interest in school, refusing to do homework or study for tests. As a consequence, his grades plummeted. His parents tried to boost their son’s confidence by assuring him that he was very smart. But their attempts failed to motivate Marcus (who is a composite drawn from several children). Schoolwork, their son maintained, was boring and pointless.
My own conclusion is that children who meet no challenge in their early schoolwork miss the opportunity to struggle early in life, when they are best able to learn from the experience. Eventually, even the most intelligent person will encounter a problem that does not admit of easy solution. An average student will learn while still very young that answers aren't handed to him, but must be wrested from the universe with much study and effort. The gifted student may not encounter this harsh reality until college or graduate school, when his approach to learning and problem-solving is already well established and may be difficult or impossible to change. Hence my frustration with the American educational system, which in the main deprives young, smart children of the opportunities they need to develop one of life's most essential skills: perseverence in the face of difficulty.
The article suggests another dimension to the problem, and what's better, an approach to counteracting it. "Helpless" students have a fixed mind-set about intelligence, viewing it as something inborn and generally unchangeable. "Mastery-oriented" students believe intelligence is malleable, and have what the authors call a growth mind-set. Unfortunately, telling our children that they are smart, and allowing them to be labelled as "gifted and talented," encourages the former view. We would do well, instead, to praise them for hard work and persistence, and emphasize to them that the brain, like a muscle, grows with exercise.
[M]ore than 30 years of scientific investigation suggests that an overemphasis on intellect or talent leaves people vulnerable to failure, fearful of challenges and unwilling to remedy their shortcomings.
[C]hildren...who coast through the early grades [in school] under the dangerous notion that no-effort academic achievement defines them as smart or gifted....hold an implicit belief that intelligence is innate and fixed, making striving to learn seem far less important than being (or looking) smart. This belief also makes them see challenges, mistakes and even the need to exert effort as threats to their ego rather than as opportunities to improve. And it causes them to lose confidence and motivation when the work is no longer easy for them.
The students with a stagnant view of intelligence were presumably unwilling to admit to their deficit and thus passed up the opportunity to correct it.
Mind-set can affect the quality and longevity of personal relationships as well, through people’s willingness—or unwillingness—to deal with difficulties. Those with a fixed mind-set are less likely than those with a growth mind-set to broach problems in their relationships and to try to solve them....After all, if you think that human personality traits are more or less fixed, relationship repair seems largely futile. Individuals who believe people can change and grow, however, are more confident that confronting concerns in their relationships will lead to resolutions.
How do we transmit a growth mind-set to our children? One way is by telling stories about achievements that result from hard work. For instance, talking about math geniuses who were more or less born that way puts students in a fixed mind-set, but descriptions of great mathematicians who fell in love with math and developed amazing skills engenders a growth mind-set, our studies have shown. People also communicate mind-sets through praise. Although many, if not most, parents believe that they should build up a child by telling him or her how brilliant and talented he or she is, our research suggests that this is misguided.
In studies involving several hundred fifth graders published in 1998, [we] gave children questions from a nonverbal IQ test. After the first 10 problems, on which most children did fairly well, we praised them. We praised some of them for their intelligence: “Wow … that’s a really good score. You must be smart at this.” We commended others for their effort: “Wow … that’s a really good score. You must have worked really hard.” We found that intelligence praise encouraged a fixed mind-set more often than did pats on the back for effort. Those congratulated for their intelligence, for example, shied away from a challenging assignment—they wanted an easy one instead—far more often than the kids applauded for their effort. (Most of those lauded for their hard work wanted the difficult problem set from which they would learn.) When we gave everyone hard problems anyway, those praised for being smart became discouraged, doubting their ability. And their scores, even on an easier problem set we gave them afterward, declined as compared with their previous results on equivalent problems. In contrast, students praised for their effort did not lose confidence when faced with the harder questions, and their performance improved markedly on the easier problems that followed.
[Some colleagues and I] recently designed an eight-session workshop for 91 students whose math grades were declining in their first year of junior high. Forty-eight of the students received instruction in study skills only, whereas the others attended a combination of study skills sessions and classes in which they learned about the growth mind-set and how to apply it to schoolwork.
In the growth mind-set classes, students read and discussed an article entitled “You Can Grow Your Brain.” They were taught that the brain is like a muscle that gets stronger with use and that learning prompts neurons in the brain to grow new connections. From such instruction, many students began to see themselves as agents of their own brain development. Students who had been disruptive or bored sat still and took note. One particularly unruly boy looked up during the discussion and said, “You mean I don’t have to be dumb?”
As the semester progressed, the math grades of the kids who learned only study skills continued to decline, whereas those of the students given the growth-mind-set training stopped falling and began to bounce back to their former levels.
Teaching children such information is not just a ploy to get them to study. People do differ in intelligence, talent and ability. And yet research is converging on the conclusion that great accomplishment, and even what we call genius, is typically the result of years of passion and dedication and not something that flows naturally from a gift. Mozart, Edison, Curie, Darwin and Cézanne were not simply born with talent; they cultivated it through tremendous and sustained effort.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues
I've written often enough about threats to the fundamental right of parents to educate their own children: the dreadful situation for homeschoolers in Germany, my concerns for Switzerland, and the unwarranted judicial intrusion in family life and education touched closer to home, in California. California ultimately upheld the legitimacy of home education, but it appears North Carolina is the next battleground.
As with the Terri Schiavo case, it is family problems that allowed the court's nose into this tent. It illustrates a serious problem with our "no fault" attitude towards divorce: despite the husband's admitted, ongoing, adulterous affair, his desire to send his children to public school has been allowed to trump his wife's desire to continue homeschooling. What is truly worrisome, as it touches homeschooling is the judge's power and attitude, as well as whatever precedent his decision may set.(Quotations are from two separate articles, here and here.)
[Venessa] Mills was forced to defend her right to homeschool during divorce proceedings brought on by her husband's unfaithfulness.....Even with abundant evidence showing the Mills children are well adjusted and well educated, Judge [Ned] Mangum ruled overwhelmingly against Mrs. Mills on every point. He stated the children would do better in public school despite the fact that they are currently at or beyond their grade level. Evidence showed two children tested several grades ahead.
When issuing his verdict Judge Mangum stated his decision was not ideologically or religiously motivated. However, he told Mrs. Mills public school will "challenge the ideas you've taught them."
The judge...explained his goal in ordering the children to register and attend a public school was to make sure they have a "more well-rounded education."
"I thought Ms. Mills had done a good job [in homeschooling]," he said. "It was great for them to have that access, and [I had] no problems with homeschooling. I said public schooling would be a good complement."
The judge said the husband has not been supportive of his wife's homeschooling, and "it accomplished its purposes. It now was appropriate to have them back in public school."
I can't help wondering what qualifies the judge to determine that the family's homeschooling had "accomplished its purposes." What purposes? Purposes for whom?
Mangum said he made the determination on his guiding principle, "What's in the best interest of the minor children," and conceded it was putting his judgment in place of the mother's.
What, indeed? Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.[T]he judge also ordered a mental health evaluation for the mother – but not the father – as part of the divorce proceedings, in what [family friend and fellow homeschooler Robyn Williams] described as an attack on the "mother's conservative Christian beliefs."
"This judge clearly took personal issue with Venessa's stance on education and faith, even though her children are doing great. If her right to homeschool can be taken away so easily, what will this mean for homeschoolers state wide, or even nationally?" Williams asked.
"What is VPK?" asks an article in our city's magazine.
Pre-math, pre-reading and social skills. How do I teach my child all this information before she enters kindergarten? Many parents used to ask themselves that precise question not too long ago. However, for the past four years, concerned parents have decided to enroll their children in what is called VPK, or voluntary pre-kindergarten education....VPK is free [that is, tax-funded]...regardless of family income.
Since the program was implemented, the results have been remarkable. First, the program gives the child the opportunity to interact with teachers, that is, people other than their parents, in whose company they've been for most of their lives. Their social skills improve as they learn to share, respect and communicate their feelings to adults and other children. Second, it gives children the freedom to express their creativity, emotion and innovation: They create cities from building blocks, show their feelings through paper and crayons and learn new ways to use everyday objects—a paper plate becomes a hat, a pipe cleaner becomes a coiled snake. VPK also brings joy, happiness and excitement to the child's family—as well as the community—when our youngsters are seen developing their intellectual side and growing as individuals at an early age.
Precisely the skills and experiences which from time immemorial children have learned...at home.
I can accept that there may be a few aberrant families in which the children interact with no one other than their parents, have neither sibling nor playmate with whom to learn to share, and have no access to crayons, blocks, paper plates, pots and pans, rocks, sticks, furniture, blankets, and all the other paraphernalia with which children "express their creativity," i.e. play. These children do, indeed, deserve all the outside assistance we can give them. But if such families are not exceedingly rare, we are in bigger trouble than an extra year in school can begin to fix. VPK is not a program for the extremely deprived; it is billed and funded as an important pre-kindergarten activity for every child. It is presently voluntary, but kindergarten was once voluntary, too. Technically kindergarten is still optional in Florida...unless you want your child to attend first grade, for which kindergarten is a prerequisite.
How much the world has changed in my memory! Some for the better, some for the worse...but the trend away from home seems to me an evil one. Our clothes are made in China and our meals in a restaurant; someone else mows our lawns and teaches our children how to play with blocks. Is home no more than a place to sleep?Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues Random Musings
As with most First Things articles, David B. Hart's 2004 essay Freedom and Decency is intellectual, dense, long, and not easy going. But—again like most First Things articles—it is well worth the effort. (Hat tip to John C. Wright. Who says science fiction writers can't be deep thinkers?) What earns the article its own post rather than a brief mention in my "Casting the Net" series is the following extraordinary paragraph, which leaps from the somewhat dry erudition with the shock of a striking panther.
I am not convinced that we are in any very meaningful sense in the midst of a “culture war”; I think it might at best be described as a fracas. I do not say that such a war would not be worth waging. Yet most of us have already unconsciously surrendered to the more insidious aspects of modernity long before we even contemplate drawing our swords from their scabbards and inspecting them for rust. This is not to say that there are no practical measures for those who wish in earnest for the battle to be joined: homeschooling or private “trivium” academies; the disposal or locking away of televisions; prohibitions on video games and popular music; Greek and Latin; great books; remote places; archaic enthusiasms. It is generally wise to seek to be separate, to be in the world but not of it, to be no more engaged with modernity than were the ancient Christians with the culture of pagan antiquity; and wise also to cultivate in our hearts a generous hatred toward the secular order, and a charitable contempt. Probably the most subversive and effective strategy we might undertake would be one of militant fecundity: abundant, relentless, exuberant, and defiant childbearing. Given the reluctance of modern men and women to be fruitful and multiply, it would not be difficult, surely, for the devout to accomplish — in no more than a generation or two — a demographic revolution. Such a course is quite radical, admittedly, and contrary to the spirit of the age, but that is rather the point, after all. It would mean often forgoing certain material advantages, and forfeiting a great deal of our leisure; it would often prove difficult to sustain a two-career family or to be certain of a lavish retirement. But if it is a war we want, we should not recoil from sacrifice.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues Random Musings
A couple more quick takes, as I dig through the backlog.
Think Your Kid's Gifted? You're Probably Wrong, from Geek Dad. An unfortunate title, as is the similar title of the article on which he is commenting; I would have said instead, "You're Probably Right." At long last parents are beginning to realize that children are not mindless lumps of clay, but are nearly all born brilliant. (You doubt that? Plunk yourself down in the middle of a foreign country and see how long it takes you to become fluent in the language.) Finally people are realizing that what they do, or don't do, with their young chldren makes a difference, and that they need better opportunities than most of them get. Why do some people feel it necessary to debunk the idea? Probably because, being fallen humans, we tend to focus not on "my child is brilliant" but "my child is brighter than someone else's child." Geek Dad catches the real issue, however.It doesn't matter if my son (or my daughter, in a few years) is officially deemed "gifted." All that matters is that my kids get the best education we can provide for them. Based on his experience in kindergarten and first grade, I'm certain my son will do better in the G/T classes, and that is really the only reason that matters for my wife and me to push hard to get him into the program.
Whether or not your kids get fitted with the label "gifted" doesn't matter. All that matters is that you do what you need to do to get your kids the very best education possible for your kids and for their specific needs. That may or may not be the same education all the other kids are getting, or your next-door neighbor's kids are getting, and that's all right. If you do what needs to be done to get your kids the best education possible, you've done your job well.
Easier said than done, especially when "best education" must cover social, spiritual, emotional, and physical issues as well as intellectual ones. Although I have an obvious prejudice in favor of home education on all fronts, what really matters is awareness, flexibility, and freedom. What is best now might not be best in three years. Above all, make sure that the person making (and evaluating) educational decisions for your children is you (that is, you, your spouse, and your children together). Not the state, not your friends, not habit and custom, and not even your well-meaning mother-in-law. :)
And speaking of the genius of babies, here are three worthwhile discussions of young children and mathematics. The initial question was "My two-year-old can verbalize the answer to almost any other factual question, and and clearly knows the answers to arithmetic problems I must check with a calculator. But he can't verbalize the math answers. Why not?" From Doman Inspired Parenting: Math (Dots) and the follow-up, Math Dots; and from Life with a Preschooler: The Math Mystery.
This brought to mind the stage Janet went through several years later, in which she balked at being asked to show her work on math assignments. She knew the answer, period—and was right 99% of the time—but could no more put the workings of her brain on paper than she could fly."If you ask a fluent reader to explain how they read they would simple state that they can. It is possible that the mental manipulation of quantity develops to the stage where the entire process takes place at a subconscious level."
If math was simply about memorizing a set of facts—What is the capital of France? Who was the fifth President? What sound does the letter A make?—it would simply be a matter of recalling the correct answer, the corresponding fact. But math, in the way that babies can do it, is not about memorizing facts: it is a way of thinking and reasoning.
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Education Children & Family Issues Random Musings
Take time out of your Christmas Rush and enjoy this offering from the Von Tone-Deaf Family Singers. :)
(Hat tip to Jennifer at Conversion Diary.)
Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues
With both of our girls we participated in the wonderful YMCA Swim and Gym classes from the time they were a few months old. The Y no longer offers this great class—the organization officially no longer believes infants should learn to swim, much to the distress of Floridians who know how important it is. Be that as it may, these twice-weekly parent/child sessions were one of the best parenting decisions we ever made, and lots of fun besides.
Having little ones who can swim well has its consequences. For one thing, you freak out all the other folks at a public pool when your child launches herself into the deep end, while you remain in your lounge chair, calmly watching her swim the length of the pool and climb out.For another, when your toddler disappears during a visit to Key Largo, you panic because you fear she has been kidnapped, not because—as you later discover—her explorations have taken her around the hotel pool and down to the docks.
And finally, when your barely-three-year-old little girl slips and tumbles, fully clothed, into your own pool, your first thought is not of rescue, but of documentation.
Those swimming lessons were a great investment, made when we were 1300 miles from Florida and infinitely far from thinking we'd ever own a house with a pool. We participated more for having something fun to do together than from any thought of water safety.Permalink | Comments | Edit
Category Children & Family Issues





